I drove Ohio back roads to my boyhood hometown a fortnight or so ago. I attended the 90th birthday party of my mother’s cousin Jerry.
He’s had a full life as a father, entrepreneur and musician. His father was an even more gifted musician. His brother Bob worked, as my mother did, for the United States Department of Justice. He was an FBI agent in the early years of the bureau.
I don’t think Cousin Bob, or Patricia Carton Burris, could have imagined a country in which many citizens distrust or disrespect the FBI and the Department of Justice. And I get that there are reasons for their disillusionment, from J. Edgar Hoover to Peter Strzok and Lisa Page. But, generally, Americans in the 1950s, say, shared confidence in and respect for American institutions.
More innocent then
We were more innocent then. The 1970’s changed that. Vietnam was the first of our modern forever wars. And the Pentagon Papers showed that the government was quite capable of systematic deceit and coverup.
Governments, like persons, tend toward misbehavior. The question is, what checks and balances have we got?
Well, we have an intricate and ingenious machinery of countervailing and separated powers, majority restraints and minority rights, and federalism. We also once had a common political culture — one of compromise and confidence. We believed in the fundamental decency of each other, and that because of this, our nation would endure.
But, in the 1970s, the country also began to divide into two cultures. One was the culture of protest and the other of civic piety. One wanted to end poverty and unjust wars and the other believed in duty and nation. One saw Martin Luther King as a prophet and the other saw Billy Graham that way.
At times each side was as right as it was righteous. But the tragic error is that we let the middle ground slip away.
Today, the woke culture has contempt, real contempt, for church goers; believers who read the Bible or pray the Rosary. And populist culture has contempt for the Rainbow flag, yoga, and the government upon whom it depends.
The metrosexual would not be caught dead listening to country music. The good old boy is not going to give Kendrick Lamar or Stravinsky a listen.
The closing of two minds
America used to be the most socially and intellectually open country in the world. What happened? The simultaneous closing of two separate and opposing American minds — two that, increasingly, do not touch. “We don’t talk to each other,” says historian Allen Guelzo.
In the seventies, we fought. In 2023, we have no use for each other: There is nothing good about Joe Biden. There was never anything good about Donald Trump and his “deplorables.”
We are untying, unbinding. It is the great divorce. And, so, when I write about Mr. Trump’s current difficulties, many people respond in terms of Trump’s fate. He is either a victim of a witch hunt and should be vindicated with another presidency. Or, he should be in jail.
Nothing less in either case. Neither view is rational. But neither view is, finally, patriotic.
The question is not what happens to Mr. Trump. The question is Lincoln’s: How do we hold the country together? How to preserve the union; the Republic. We don’t see this. We have too little connection. We have broken too many bonds.
America has never had a strong sense of history. It has been all about invention and “the new.” This has increasingly atomized and then tribalized us.
Lives inseparable from their towns
We must teach American ideas again, so that native born Americans feel the “mystic chords of memory” as clearly as new citizens do. National service would reintroduce us to each other and force us to talk, as universal military service once did. The nation needs a religious revival, and a new King and a new Graham, so that we understand the basis of decency and respect. “We are not enemies, but friends.”
I drove the back roads looking for small-town America, and largely found it gone. I had a similar experience on a drive through the backroads of the South a few years back. We need a Marshall Plan to rebuild small town America — a thing that is as much a part of our civic skeletal structure as the union movement.
There was family talk at Jerry’s party, but also much town talk. My grandfather’s and father’s lives were inseparable from the town’s; their lives inextricable from civic life. This was not political. It was filial. I recall my Dad stopping to talk with a wonderful lady down the street, car window to car window, simply because they were neighbors and it had been a while.
You can’t have contempt for a neighbor.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Prosecuting Donald Trump could backfire.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.