An international court in The Hague issues an arrest warrant for the president of a foreign nation charging him with war crimes. When the arrest warrant is announced, international observers doubt that this sitting president will soon cede power, let alone find himself on trial.
Sound familiar?
These facts could describe the indictment of Russian President Vladimir Putin for war crimes committed in Ukraine. But instead, I’m referencing Slobodan Milošević, the former Serbian leader indicted for war crimes committed in Kosovo, a state that would later declare itself independent from Serbia.
An Iron grip
Milošević ruled Serbia with an iron grip when the United Nations International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) indicted him in 1999. Few expected him to ever see the inside of a foreign courtroom. Just over two years later, however, Milošević found himself sitting in the dock, after his arrest by Serbian officials. He died in his jail cell in The Hague in 2006 before the court reached a verdict.
After the International Criminal Court (ICC) issued an international arrest warrant for Vladimir Putin for war crimes, the reaction mirrored those when Milošević was first indicted. The arrest warrant offered a big step toward recognizing the war crimes committed in Ukraine, observers agreed. In the near term, however, the odds of Putin’s imminent arrest are slim.
Read More
Still, individuals protected by powerful interests can find themselves friendless when political winds change. Take Félicien Kabuga, currently on trial at the United Nations International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals for acts committed during the Rwandan genocide. Once one of the richest men in Rwanda, Kabuga relied on multiple aliases and powerful connections in foreign governments to evade capture for two decades. His support network had withered to his family when he was arrested in a Paris suburb in 2020.
Another Rwandan fugitive, Fulgence Kayishema, was indicted in 2001 for his alleged involvement in the killing of 2000 Tutsi seeking shelter a church during the Rwandan genocide. He was arrested earlier this year following years on the run.
The old saw might be that justice delayed is justice denied, but when it comes to international justice, more time can mean stronger evidence.
Such is the case with Ratko Mladić, the Bosnian Serb Army general indicted for the 1995 Srebrenica genocide, among other crimes. The Srebrenica genocide included an elaborate re-burial effort to hide the crimes. When the ICTY handed down its first genocide conviction in 2001, one judge even noted the recovery of “very few mortal remains.” Without question, the prosecution case for genocide would have been weaker had Mladić gone to trial shortly after his indictment. Instead, he went on the run.
By the time of Mladić’s arrest in 2011, UN investigators had found key evidence behind a false wall in Mladić’s home, obtained testimony from insider witnesses, and, critically, located mass graves that proved Mladić’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt for the genocide of 7,000 Bosnian men and boys. Military orders and witness testimony indicated the military chain of command. Forensic investigators identified causes of deaths, recovered ligatures that tied decedents’ hands, and testified to the DNA identification process.
Putin stands accused
Putin stands accused of war crimes related to the forcible transfer of children from Ukraine to Russia. While Putin remains at large, international investigators in Ukraine continue to gather evidence, allowing for the potential of additional charges and a stronger prosecution case.
Key differences exist between a war crimes trial against Putin and past cases. Russia is a nuclear power with a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council. Having never joined the ICC, Russia has been quick to reject the validity of that court’s warrant.
Moreover, the ICC may not be the body that ultimately prosecutes Putin. Beth Van Schaack, the U.S. Ambassador for Global Criminal Justice, has announced U.S. support for a special tribunal to try the crime of aggression, an unlawful invasion of another country.
In the short term, the ICC arrest warrant has already limited Putin’s travel, contributing to his absence at a key economic conference in South Africa. The warrant may also play a future role in the lifting of sanctions against Russia. Putin has used his years at the helm to consolidate power and support. But if recent history is any guide, such wells of support may not spring eternal.
Cody Corliss, a former war crimes prosecutor at two United Nations international tribunals, is an associate professor at West Virginia University College of Law.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.