On that one specific page of what the memory has tucked into family history, our battered Chevy was likely deemed not up to the task, which is why we rode the bus, my father and I, to Philadelphia from the hard coal regions on a bone cold Sunday morning.
Our purpose was perfectly clear to me. I was 13, and the part of my life in which I’d never seen an NFL game was about to become history, and it felt momentous. My father’s purpose was a little larger. The bus left at 7 a.m., meaning we’d have hours to kill in the city, and he was determined to fill them with actual history that was actually momentous.
So that became our pregame show, an hours long walking tour of America’s founding through Philadelphia’s historical landmarks, Liberty Bell, Independence Hall, all of it. Since portions of it were closed on Sunday, much of the tour was conducted by him, and his credentials were beyond suspicion. He was unquestionably one of the best-read mailmen in town, and I believe the contemporary roster was four.
Denying history
What stayed with me more than any particular thing that we saw that morning was how important it was to him that I saw it, that I stood where the Founders stood, risking their lives and inventing a new country, determining what to commit to the Declaration of Independence 250 years ago this summer, and later to the Constitution of the United States.
By sundown it seemed all but eclipsed by Eagles 33, Browns 21, but in this moment not 60 years later, our history is threatened every day by the very government it willed into existence. Such a thing was inconceivable when we walked around Philadelphia. Then it was merely impossible. Then it was here.
In the Philadelphia of January 2026, crowbars were used to remove outdoor panels and plaques at the site of George Washington’s former home on Independence Mall. The markers told the story of nine people who’d been enslaved there as part of a relatively new exhibit commissioned by the city and the National Parks Service to examine the “paradox between slavery and freedom in the founding of the nation.”
The Trump administration considers such presentations woke nonsense, of course, and as long as there is a Trump administration, the Trump administration will permit the teaching of history only in the ways that don’t make the Trump administration uncomfortable.
The city promptly sued the administration, followed quickly by the state, where the governor rose to the argument:
“Donald Trump will take any opportunity to rewrite and whitewash our history, but he picked the wrong city and the wrong Commonwealth,” said Josh Shapiro. “In Pennsylvania, we learn from our history, even when it’s painful. We don’t erase it or pretend it didn’t happen. Because when we know where we’ve been, we can chart a better course for the future. Those displays aren’t just signs — they represent our shared history, and if we want to move forward as a nation, we have to be willing to tell the full story of where we came from.”
Unlearning history
Though that statement came with the customary three coats of polish Shapiro hopes to ride to what’s left of the White House, the legal arguments in this case were the far flashier.
Citing the president’s executive order known as “Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History,” administration lawyer Gregory in den Berken argued last Friday that “reasonable minds can differ as to what needs to be displayed, what needs to be shown, how it needs to be shown. Ultimately, it is the National Park Service and federal government’s choice ... the government gets to choose the message it wants to convey.”
The judge in the case, Cynthia Rufe, a George W. Bush appointee, somehow managed not to leap over the bench at him.
“That is a dangerous statement you are making,” she said. “It is horrifying to listen to. (History) changes on the whims of someone in charge? I’m sorry, that is not what we elected anybody for. You can’t change history once you’ve learned it. It doesn’t work that way.”
But what if you didn’t learn it?
With Trump, there’s always a loophole.
The president’s knowledge of history (and many other things) is famously sketchy, lest you’ve forgotten his praise of Revolutionary War troops “taking over the airports.” The history he thinks he’s sure of is the stuff that includes “corrosive” or “improper ideology,” a notably high percentage of which has to do with Black history.
Erasing history
No wonder that as Black History Month begins, no less historically authoritative institution than the Smithsonian finds itself forced to comply with an administration directive to align its exhibits, materials, and operations with Trump’s views and to remove “divisive narratives,” such as, in the president’s words “how bad Slavery was.”
“We are not going to allow this to happen,” Trump said in a social media post last year, “and I have instructed my attorneys to go through the Museums, and start the exact same process that has been done with Colleges and Universities where tremendous progress has been made.”
In an America actively being made dumber, sicker, and less secure every single day, restoring truth and sanity might be a greater challenge than even the founders could have imagined.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “Waiting for the tipping point, looking for the vanishing helpers.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.