When Pittsburgh’s baseball team lost on Saturday in Minneapolis, its eighth loss in a row and the 58th of another desultory summer now mercifully paused by the All-Star break, the city’s decaying relationship with its pathetic Pirates collided with a stunning statistical outcropping.

For the first time since 1903, when they first profiled as a winning operation, their all-time record had finally flat-lined to perfect mediocrity; they had won 10,877 games since starting play in the late 1800’s and they had lost 10,877 games. And though they won the next day, this flailing at the historical water line will resurface in their dark narrative this weekend, as it should.

Rarely have the now-and-again beloved Buccos been subjected to such current levels of abject revulsion in their long-term relationship with the city and the region. That relationship needs counseling, and as providence would have it, the perfect therapist was sitting across the table from me the other day — Sister Mary Jane Beatty, Sisters of Divine Providence.

Pirates high and lows

“When they won those six games in a row, I said to somebody, ‘Who are those people wearing the Pirate uniforms?’” she began. “It was like night and day. Talk about highs and lows.”

Advertise with us

We were at The Commons at Providence Heights in Allison Park, an easy relay throw from where Sister had taken her history degree at LaRoche. A master’s in counseling from Duquesne would follow as well as more post-graduate work at Pitt in marriage and family therapy, but mostly what Sister Mary Jane was bringing to the table was a singular baseball DNA first transmitted by her father’s radio at 2214 Wilson Street in Wheeling. That was — what? — 10,000 Pirates games ago, 12,000, who’s counting?

“The Pirates are an integral part of Pittsburgh, so important to Pittsburgh,” she said. “The give hope and they struggle. We struggle, they struggle. It’s a symbiotic relationship of sorts. Great joys and terrible seasons. Why have I always been so attracted to the Pirates? It’s just part of who I am, it’s a connection, and the Pirates are a very important connection for Pittsburgh and Pittsburgh culture.”

Sister’s connection is deeper than most. She was close with the late Sister Mary Paul Doyle, a friend and language mentor to the young Roberto Clemente as he was learning about connections. It was with Sister Mary Paul that she attended her first game, June 23, 1971, the ticket stub from which landed on the table top within minutes. ($3, plus tax).

She was a confidant of former Pirates pitcher Kris Benson, who once phoned her at the Motherhouse at 3 a.m. in a time zone mix-up, and though she’s seen plenty of memorable baseball including Bob Gibson’s no-hitter against the Pirates at Three Rivers Stadium, and became a Starbucks buddy and email exchanger with former Pirates manager Clint Hurdle, her most enduring memory is of that first day at the ballpark.

“Being able to look at Roberto Clemente that first time, not knowing then the history that would go into it, it was so, so impressive. He’d gotten tickets for Sister Mary Paul and I drove her down there from Sharpsburg. Before the game started, we just walked down to the rail and talked with him. He seemed gentle, a nice guy, quiet.”

Advertise with us

A hotwire to God

Four decades later, after Mass one Sunday, she cruised over to the Starbucks on McKnight Road and happened upon Hurdle.

“I met a lot of Pittsburghers at Starbucks,” Hurdle was saying on the phone the other day. “We kept bumping into each other and I starting thinking, ‘Here’s my hotwire to God,’ and we really needed that my first two years in Pittsburgh. I said we’ve got to lock arms and you have to pray me up.”

Sister “had a passion for Bucco baseball and a heart of gold. She serves her God in a very steadfast way. Once she came with some other sisters to a spring training game in Fort Myers. We had three sisters on the field outfitted in baseball gear and it was really sweet. That’s almost 14 years ago now.”

Only last month, Hurdle and his wife Karla were honored guests with Roberto Clemente Jr. at a gala for Anchorpoint Counseling Ministry, where Sister counseled for some 30 years. She likes to note that Hurdle missed her 25th anniversary celebration there, “because he was getting his Manager of the Year Award, but he sent a jersey and all kinds of gifts.”

So the Pirates are back at it Friday night, and Sister Mary Jane will be watching or listening, starting with the pre-game show, like she does. I came back to the therapy. Why are they so depressing and why do people keep caring?

Advertise with us

Put it on the owner

“Well, it gets put on the owner,” she said. “He’s from Wheeling too; I don’t say that to too many people. But when you have a passion for baseball, it just gets the juices going. There’s something soothing about the pace of it, the rhythm of how the game goes. You have to be able to handle loss and you can’t dwell on it.”

She continued: “That’s life. Let go of it and start over. I’m trying to help them now, to start over. That six-game winning streak was just unbelievable, and so was losing the next eight.”

“They don’t deserve you Sister,” I said. “You’re a great Pirates fan.”

“And I will be.”

Gene Collier’s previous column was “For a moment, let's not bee terrorized.”