Tired of this interminable squawking parade of radical left lunatics bellyaching about the Trump administration’s dramatic cuts to the United States Agency for International Development (USAID)?
Me too, so let’s focus in this little essay on the bellyaching from Congressional Trumpublicans and long-revered fiscal conservatives on the very same topic.
You don’t much need radical left lunatics when there’s readily available depravity all around.
Day 1 dismantling
When the new administration set about on Day 1 the dismantling of USAID, an agency that spends nearly $40 billion annually in foreign assistance, first by pausing all programs for 90 days and then putting nearly all personnel on leave by Feb. 5, the need for some plausible explanation wasn’t lost on Congress, even as that institution’s vanishing role in Trump 2.0 was becoming painfully evident.
In a country where a lot of people think foreign aid is 25% of the budget, even though it’s about 1%, there has to be accountability, right?
So last Thursday, three days after the Associated Press reported hundreds of millions of dollars worth of lifesaving commodities were rotting away because USAID staff was now prohibited from delivering it, Florida Republican Brian Mast called a hearing in the House of Representatives under the working title “The USAID Betrayal.”
But things slipped sideways pretty quickly, and Republicans were at a loss to regain control.
Rep. Young Kim, the California Republican who chairs the House Foreign Affairs East Asia and Pacific Subcommittee, went straight to the zeal with which foreign enemies are just about ecstatic over America’s USAID sledgehammer.
Chinese President Xi Jinping “is watching and he is waiting for the chance to fill any U.S. vacuum,” she said. “Already there have been many reports of Chinese Communist Party officials signaling their willingness to replace USAID in Nepal and (taking over) de-mining activities in Cambodia, and these are just the instances that we know about. Even critics of USAID acknowledge the critical soft power of targeted and efficient programming.”
Mast held his ground, saying that some of the money spent by USAID is indefensible, like money to support tourism in Egypt and Tunisia, adding that America would be better off had that money been “thrown into a fireplace.”
Trump’s utter nonsense
That’s when Andrew Natsios, a professor in the Bush School of Government at Texas A&M and for most of his public life a Republican operative in the developing world, including as the former Administrator of USAID, started explaining that tourism is 12% of GDP in Egypt, and “development tourism” has been coordinated by USAID in Lebanon, Tunisia, Kosovo, and Bosnia.
“I’m a conservative Republican who believes in fiscal responsibility,” Natsios said. “I was named Legislator of the Year by Citizens for Limited Taxation in Massachusetts in the 1980s. To me, foreign aid was never a ‘criminal’ enterprise as Elon Musk has said — it was delivering textbooks to village schools, responding to disease outbreaks, ending child trafficking, preventing mass starvation, and providing economic opportunities.”
As administrator of USAID, he continued, “I always sought to uphold USAID’s mission, to promote and demonstrate democratic values abroad, and advance a free, peaceful, and prosperous world. While I share Mr. Musk’s concerns over our national debt, I believe that shutting down our aid program is a mistake.”
Trump and Musk see it a little differently, maybe you’ve heard, with the president offering his usual highly-nuanced opinion that USAID is “a tremendous fraud,” even though both Melania Trump and Ivanka Trump visited USAID supported missions in Africa during his first term and found them inspiring. Be Best!
It wasn’t until Natsios went on “60 Minutes” Sunday night to call Trump’s comments “utter nonsense,” that Musk posted on X his considered view that maybe the whole operation should be locked up. “60 Minutes are the biggest liars in the world!” Musk raged. “They engaged in deliberate deception to interfere with the last election. They deserve a long prison sentence.”
Getting slammed for election interference by a guy who just spent some $290 million to put Trump in the White House isn’t likely to phase Natsios, whose real temerity was explaining that “The most accountable aid agency in the world is USAID. I have actually written widely on this subject. Forty percent of the staff are accountants and lawyers and people trying to make sure no money is stolen.”
Suffering accelerates
In the meantime, the real life suffering accelerates by the day as the world’s richest man, Musk, with a reported $13 billion in government contracts stuffed into his portfolio over the past five years, effectively tells the world’s poorest children they’ve been freeloading for too long.
According to War Child International, the non-governmental charity that monitors and supports children in areas of global conflict, America’s aid suspension “looks increasingly like a collapse of the whole USAID agency. This is going to leave some of the world’s most vulnerable children without the support they need to learn and heal and thrive. Children in conflict zones — like Sudan, Gaza, Syria, and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) — are now without education, protection, mental health support or safe spaces where they can just be a child again and get the help they need.”
It all sounds as though the working title of that Congressional hearing — USAID Betrayal — is going to be embarrassingly accurate.
Gene Collier’s previous column was “America needs a Navalny.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.