For some inexplicable reason, American history seems freshest in the summer, perhaps from the solemn re-examinations of Normandy in June and of Gettysburg in July and of V-J Day in August, and as usual because we are never more than one fateful burst of channel surfing away from “Jaws.”

You heard me.

American history unavoidably includes the history of the summer blockbuster as well, with “Jaws” as the prototype. I ran across it again last week on TNT, which had no compunction about placing a fistful of its 500 commercials smack in the middle of Quint’s soliloquy about the USS Indianapolis.

The decorated World War II Navy vessel took two Japanese torpedoes to its starboard side on one terrible midnight in the Pacific, four days after completing a top-secret mission that would end the war within weeks. “So, eleven hundred men went into the water, three-hundred sixteen come out,” the actor Robert Shaw concludes as Quint, “sharks took the rest, June the 29th, 1945. ... Anyway, we delivered the bomb.”

Advertise with us

I’ve always regarded Quint’s tortured oceanic cadenza the way I’ve generally regarded the film as a whole since its record-smashing debut in 1975, as pretty much dead solid perfect, even as Shaw insisted on calling the bomb “the bum.”

Historically, you’ll not be surprised, it’s, um, less than perfect.

Here is Quint’s sentence again, somewhat annotated: “So, eleven hundred men went into the water (not exactly), 316 come out; sharks took (some of) the rest, June the 29th, 1945 (actually July the 30th, 1945), anyway, we delivered the bum” (not technically, as the bomb hadn’t been built yet).

Quint’s little speech went on for some three-and-a-half minutes, a cinematic eternity, but there’s no need to project the number of potential historical errors that might have been presented. On balance, the story he tells works beautifully as both historical framework and dramatic lynchpin. As an accomplished director once said, “As we say in theater, it’s true; it’s just not factual.”

The writing in the oft-examined early Spielberg film is credited to three writers, but the Quint speech is mostly the work of Shaw himself (he was also a playwright). Spielberg always said it was a collaborative effort. But the irony erected in the film’s quietest moments — an Indianapolis survivor about to watch the blood-sprayed start of his own digestion by a great white shark 30 years after a living World War II nightmare — is massive enough that you’re clearly going to need a bigger boat.

Advertise with us

If anything, the scene is a brilliant flash of monologue writing from a pre-internet era where facts weren’t exactly at the fingertips. Spielberg and his writers, including Shaw, might have done it differently today, when you can know within seconds that the Indianapolis left San Francisco on the 16th of July, carrying bomb parts and half the world’s enriched uranium for use in assembling Little Boy, the bomb the U.S. dropped on Hiroshima Aug. 6.

After delivering the components to Tinian island on July 26, it was sailing toward Leyte when the Japanese sub attacked. Just as Quint says at the start, the vessel went down in 12 minutes. What he doesn’t say is that 1,195 men were aboard and that some 300 went down with the ship. That left about 900 of them adrift in open water for parts of five days, battling exposure, dehydration, hypothermia, hypernatremia from ingesting salt water, hallucinations and delirium. There were multiple suicides.

Quint made it sound perfectly horrible, with the body of his friend bitten in half below the waist, etc., but he took no liberties given the fact that the actual event was far worse. Among the suicides was the ship’s captain, Charles McVay, who was initially rescued from the water among the 316, but whose subsequent court-martial weighed on him with such malignancy that he shot himself two decades later. A subsequent investigation cleared McVay of any and all responsibility in the fate of Indianapolis.

The last first-person account of the ordeal itself came from one Harold Bray, who told his local California newspaper about waiting in the water for a delayed rescue that itself seemed an impossible dream, about the blistering heat of the day and the unremitting cold at night.

“Then the sharks came,” Bray said in that 2014 interview. “I looked down and they were just swarming us. Their tails would hit me every once in a while. There wasn’t really anywhere to go; we had to deal with them. The sharks seemed to go after the people who had the big cuts to them, were naked or just in their skivvies. We lost a lot of good men in those first few days.”

Advertise with us

How many, via shark, by the time it was over?

Various sources put that number anywhere from a couple of dozen to 150, although in either case the Indianapolis remains the trigger for the greatest loss of human life by shark attack in history.

Quint may not have had the numbers right, but he nailed the horror.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @genecollier. His previous article was “My father worried I'd cut my head off.”