On the comedy stage, I’ve long poked holes in democracy, and specifically the voters. Democracy depends for its legitimacy upon an informed electorate, which, maybe you’ve noticed, is hardly assured.

So lines like, “If you think Santorum was the warm-up act for Pantera, you might consider staying home on election day,” and “If you feel that Roe vs. Wade are the options in the unlikely event of a water landing . . . stay the hell home,” always worked.

Yeah, I’m here all weekend.

But the joke is over.

Advertise with us

I mean the nerve of these Democrats in 2020, trying to use our American democracy as a referendum on . . . our American democracy.

Ordinarily I’d have saved this column for Nov. 3, Election Day, but given our toxic-to-deadly circumstances, the election is now through probably mid-November, and as complicated and contentious as that combustible process is likely to be, there is only one issue. There is only one question and it’s so simple that even the most quixotically undecided or low information voter can readily understand it.

The issue is democracy and the question is do you want it or not. Should America persist in this experiment, with all of its endemic flaws and all of its interminable argy bargy, or should it commit to authoritarianism and what smells increasingly like fascism? Not terribly long ago, this was an unthinkable rhetorical question. Not today.

Before you vote, know that 21st century fascism in America is not exactly the make-the-trains-run-on-time fascism of the monstrous Third Reich and its satellite thuggery. Much like the pandemic that helped metastasize it, American fascism will be under the supervision of a man who could not manage a hot dog cart, Donald J. Trump.

The final pieces began falling into place this week.

Advertise with us

Utah Sen. Mike Lee, last seen serving up coronavirus and taking a helping for himself in the White House Rose Garden in late September, opined that American democracy is at best overrated if not an impediment to whatever brainstorms his Republican brethren are currently entertaining.

“Democracy isn’t the objective,” Mr. Lee tweeted. “Liberty, peace, and prosperity are. We want the human condition to flourish. Rank democracy can thwart that.”

The fact that Mike Lee came to the United States Senate through the process of democracy, indeed that you’d never have heard of Mike Lee if it weren’t for democracy, is not in itself the perfect counterpoint to this little slice of idiocy. The fact that you’ve historically had to rely on the Chinese Communist Party, the Kremlin, or random murderous European and South American strongmen for that kind of statement is more compelling. Also that democracy, rather than thwart peace, prosperity, and liberty, is the world’s essential engine of all three; that would seem to be self-evident.

Not to Senator Lee.

Vice President of the United States of America Mike Pence, happily winging his own Rose Garden coronavirus exposure all the way to Utah, refused to even address the debate question of what he would do if there was not a peaceful transfer of power in the event that the Trump-Pence ticket loses.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pence’s dismissive reply included ramblings about the Trump movement, the military, the economy, the courts, policing, Democrats, FBI spying, Hillary Clinton, Mr. Trump’s impeachment, Hillary Clinton again, and voter fraud. He stopped just short of blaming Barack Obama for sending that fly to land on his head.

This came eight days after Mr. Trump himself declined to commit to a peaceful transfer of power, so apparently you’re right to anticipate there will be no such thing.

On Thursday, the FBI, after a months-long investigation, arrested 13 men linked to an alleged plot to overthrow the government of Michigan and kidnap its governor, Gretchen Whitmer. If you’re wondering, the date of Mr. Trump’s infamous “LIBERATE MICHIGAN” tweet was April 17. Not two years ago, Ms. Whitmer became the democratically elected chief executive of America’s 10th largest state, beating her Republican rival by nearly 10 points (53% to 44%). Who knew it was such a short distance to the place where you’re targeted for kidnap and God knows what else by actors linked to the Wolverine Watchmen militia?

That was less than a week after the Department of Justice, directed by Trump hand puppet Bill Barr, trashed its own long-standing policy against interfering in elections.

“Since at least 1980,” wrote Boston College history professor Heather Cox Richardson in a Facebook post, “the DOJ has barred prosecutors from announcing any investigations or making arrests or raids before an election out of fear of affecting the outcome. Now, though, if a U.S. Attorney’s office suspects election fraud, especially cases involving United States Postal Service workers or military employees, it can make an investigation public before the polls close. Because voter fraud through mail-in ballots involving the USPS and military voting have been key elements of Trump’s charge that the election will be tainted, observers are concerned that this new rule is designed to make it easier for Trump to contest the results of the election.”

Advertise with us

The thudding sounds of democracy crumbling are persistent but not new. Political desperation and potential street violence, unemployment, disease, natural disasters, unremitting racial tension are burdensomely real in contemporary America, but the rise of authoritarianism globally has been its own tumor for more than a decade. Autocrats appeal to nationalism, foment hatred of outsiders and elites, and orchestrate the backlash against more liberal cultures. As the Harvard political scientist Pippa Norris has argued, as cultures grow more egalitarian, more open to LGBTQ rights and racial equality, more expansive in democratic representation, more global, secular, and cosmopolitan, traditionalists feel threatened and marginalized. Those traditionalists are turning toward more forceful leaders who promise to halt the trends.

Mr. Trump didn’t come to power in a vacuum in 2016, but his pointed narcissism hit the repositioned American bullseye with “Only I can fix it!”

Four years later, American democracy is in a fix like few times in its history. Trump’s political acolytes continue to erect multiple structures to suppress the vote, democracy’s bloodline, particularly among Blacks, Latinos, Native Americans, the poor, the sick, and the young. Democracy’s believers have to vote. Its supporters who even suspect their right to vote is being impeded have to be more determined than ever to vote. Now. Today.

I’ve been writing for newspapers for most of a half century, but here’s a sentence I never dreamed I’d ever type. Democracy could go down in this election. Down and out.

If it’s going down, it should go down voting.

Advertise with us

Not a joke.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.