Pennsylvania’s state government has reduced its investigation of serious financial crime, leaving Keystone State residents more vulnerable to fraudsters — and abandoning its traditional position as one of America’s strongest enforcers of securities laws. A recent Post-Gazette investigation by Sean D. Hamill showed that probes into high-dollar lawbreaking have decreased in recent years, and the state apparently passed on looking into one of the biggest scams in recent years, one that cost investors over $1.6 billion.

At the same time, President Donald Trump’s commutation of the sentence of the convicted ringleader of that billion-dollar scam, David Gentile, sent an unmistakable message to aspiring fraudsters (and to hardworking Americans): Crime can still pay, as long as you’re rich, powerful and politically connected — and your victims aren’t.

Gentile was convicted of running a massive pyramid scheme while he and his partners lived the high life. The scam had a significant local connection, because the firm at the center, GPB Capital, bought two local companies in its attempts to give the appearance of financial health: the Kenny Ross auto dealer empire and waste-hauler Iron City Express.

It’s the kind of operation Pennsylvania regulators used to investigate more regularly. According to Hamill, financial crimes detectives in Harrisburg were once considered among the most experienced and aggressive in America, and were sought out to help on the biggest cases around the country.

Advertise with us

Back in 2012, as part of a deal to bring state spending in line with revenues, the General Assembly and then-Gov. Tom Corbett agreed to merge the banking and securities divisions of the state’s financial regulation arm, forming the Department of Banking and Securities.

The idea was to bring two agencies doing similar work under one roof to make them more efficient, not to kneecap them. But ever since, Pennsylvania has lost its position as a top enforcement state.

Hamill revealed that 2025 was the slowest in 12 years for enforcement actions, down about 60% from 2019. And while securities took up the lion’s share of the 44 cases they investigated, the issues were largely rinky-dink paperwork issues, not major fraud cases that could stop Pennsylvanians from being scammed, or recover their losses.

And it’s not like there’s been nothing to investigate. An experienced financial professional raised red flags to Harrisburg about the Gentile-GPB Capital case years before federal authorities, along with New York and New Jersey, broke it open. But, despite having clear jurisdictional and moral authority, Pennsylvania appears to have remained passive.

Securities fraud is generally a federal issue, and it’s true that layered state regulations can sometimes introduce unnecessary friction into the financial system. But we’re not talking about Pennsylvania enforcing arcane commonwealth rules.

Advertise with us

We’re talking about Pennsylvania enforcing basic anti-fraud laws that specifically protect Pennsylvania residents and businesses. For instance, in the Gentile case, New York and New Jersey used state laws to recover some losses for victims. Pennsylvania never even got involved, leaving Keystone Staters with possibly millions of unrecovered losses.

Gov. Josh Shapiro should look closely at the Department of Banking and Securities to see if there are structural problems holding it back and ask if the banking and securities divisions should be separated once again. A slightly more costly, but more effective, enforcement operation just might save taxpayers more than they spend on it.

Fighting fraud, however, is all the more difficult when the president himself sees fit to reward it through pardons and commutations of unrepentant crooks. A country where the rich and powerful can bully and defraud with impunity is not a country where anyone can feel secure.