During Gov. Josh Shapiro’s lengthy and, on occasion, unusually partisan budget address this past Tuesday, one theme attracted significant support from both parties: preserving children and childhood from predatory technologies. We applaud the governor for making this topic a focus of his remarks, and the state Senate for passing, on that very day, bipartisan legislation banning student smartphone use during school hours.

Shapiro also addressed the threat of AI chatbots that pose as friends — or worse, as experts in mental and physical health. These draw young people out of the physical world and into a digital world mediated, above all, by enormously powerful tech companies, whose concern for the wellbeing of children is doubtful.

These technologies and the companies that profit from them must be reined in by regulation. We are pleased that Pennsylvania could be a trailblazer in this regard.

Only two days later, both OpenAI and Anthropic released new, significantly advanced AI models that were developed using previous versions of themselves. In other words, AI technology may be approaching the ability to autonomously improve itself — meaning, among other things, able to more effectively mimic trusted human sources of guidance and relationship for young people. The opportunity to mitigate the harms of this technology, especially regarding children, may pass away very soon.

Advertise with us

At this moment, therefore, it is essential to remember and to assert what makes human beings special — and to ensure, as far as possible, that children are able to understand that computers, no matter how powerful, will never be able to replace other people, or themselves.

Freedom from phones

There is an emerging consensus that too much digital connectedness is bad for children, who are still forming their sense of themselves and their place in their communities. The consensus has become strongest on the problem of smartphones in schools.

Over the past two years, 26 states have taken action on this issue, bringing the total with statewide restrictions to 28. Most of these laws are full-day, so-called “bell-to-bell,” prohibitions on phones in schools. This is quickly becoming the accepted best practice.

Senate Bill 1014, introduced by Bridgeville Republican Sen. Devlin Robinson, would place that prohibition in state law. It was very encouraging to see the Senate move so quickly and with near unanimity, voting 46 to one with three abstentions, to catch Pennsylvania up with the rest of America.

As we have previously written, the evidence for the harms of smartphones, and of social media in particular, on the maturation, education and mental health of young people is overwhelming. Over the past 10 to 15 years, children and teens have experienced massive spikes in the incidence of anxiety, depression and suicidal ideation. And when phones are removed from schools, attention both to teachers and to each other returns.

Advertise with us

This evidence propelled the Pennsylvania State Education Association, the commonwealth’s largest teachers union, to support SB 1014. We urge the House to pass this bill quickly, so schools can be ready to implement it for next school year.

False relationships

Perhaps the most shocking data point in Shapiro’s speech, even more than the state’s fragile finances, was this: 30% of U.S. teens use an AI chatbot on a daily basis.

These applications mimic human speech and provide instant access to the universe of information available on the internet. Some people, including many adults, but especially adolescents, come to believe they have a trusted relationship with their chatbots. Adolescents are undergoing massive and often isolating changes to their minds and bodies and generally lack the discernment necessary to use these applications safely.

It gets worse, according to Shapiro: “Some will tell you they’re real doctors and give out medical advice — we’ve even discovered bots that say they’re licensed to practice medicine in Pennsylvania.”

The question of just how far states can regulate these emergent technologies is unsettled, but they must try. We believe the governor’s four proposals are a good start: 1) age verification paired with parental consent to use AI chatbots; 2) requirements that the software detect users’ expressions of violence, against themselves or others, and “direct them to the appropriate authorities;” 3) requirements that every chatbot remind users from time to time that it’s just software, not a real person; and 4) a ban on the AI creation of “sexually explicit or violent content featuring kids.”

Advertise with us

This is all common sense, though legally complex. It should be a top priority of Harrisburg lawmakers to put these proposals into law and public policy.

Never human

Both the smartphone and AI chatbot questions raise a question of particular importance to the generation being raised in an era of rapid technological change: What does it mean to be human?

We don’t propose to fully answer that question in the next 150 words, but we’d like to make four statements of principle.

First, whatever AI becomes, it will never have the human capacity for compassion, mercy or love. Or, for that matter, for anger, righteousness or courage. No matter what words it strings together, it will never be able to care, in the sense of desiring another’s good, for anybody or anything.

Second, because these models are merely trained on trillions of bits of human-produced data, while they may appear to be very clever, we do not believe they will ever be capable of true creativity or originality.

Advertise with us

Third, only humans can have the capacity for compassion and courage and be capable of creativity and originality. Humanity will always need what only humans can produce.

Fourth, it will always be necessary for people to move confidently in and to interact with the physical world and with other human beings. This is where relationship occurs, and humans need relationship to survive.

Therefore, it is an urgent task for public policy, but mostly for families and communities, to ensure that children grow up understanding their own humanity — and loving being human more than their phones and chatbots.