The day of reckoning for the mismanagement of the Gainey administration has finally arrived. Before the end of the year, the City of Pittsburgh will have to enact both spending cuts and a tax hike to avert financial disaster.
Mayor Ed Gainey’s refusal to concede that his budget is obviously unworkable, including hiding tens of millions of dollars in predictable expenditures, is a final dereliction of duty that will further tarnish his legacy. Nothing has made this clearer than the unanimous “will of council” resolution passed this Tuesday, which reads that the budget “does not represent a spending plan that adequately serves the needs of Pittsburgh residents,” and called on the mayor to use the resources available to the executive branch to fix it.
Four councilmembers who supported Gainey’s re-election joined the resolution. They have, finally, had enough. The administration, however, has not cooperated, leaving Council to fix the budget itself.
However: Eight of nine members of City Council — outgoing Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith is the exception — are in no position to complain about having to make these hard choices. That’s because, despite repeated warnings from this Editorial Board and City Controller Rachael Heisler, they voted to pass Gainey’s disastrous 2025 budget, which included the same financial sleights of hand as the 2026 edition.
At the eleventh hour — with only three weeks before a hard Jan. 1 deadline that, if passed, would likely result in the full closure of all city offices and furloughing of all city employees — Council is working to rectify the Gainey administration’s incompetence, and its own complicity in it. It will be impossible to do so without increasing property taxes; but in a show of good faith to taxpayers, this must be accompanied by tangible spending cuts.
Necessary hike
To review, while Gainey’s proposed 2026 budget is nominally “balanced,” as required by state law, it obscures at least $30 million in predictable expenditures, including union raises and overtime expenses. If the budget were passed as-is, it would likely result in Pittsburgh operating in the red for consecutive years while devastating its reserves — a recipe for a return to Act 47 state oversight.
In order to head this off, Councilwoman Barb Warwick has introduced a 30% property tax increase, which would raise a little over $40 million per year. This proposal should be understood as a tacit admission of Gainey’s gross financial mismanagement by one of his biggest supporters.
It should also be understood as an opening gambit — one that is likely to be politically costly for Warwick. But someone had to put his or her name to the legislation opening negotiations. Her doing so is honorable.
We don’t believe Pittsburgh needs a 30% tax hike, and there certainly isn’t an appetite for one on Council. However, the city hasn’t increased its millage in a decade, during the first (and hopefully only) round of Act 47 oversight. In the intervening years, Allegheny County municipalities have increased their property taxes by an average of about — 30%. Across the country, residential property tax bills are, on average, are increasing over 5% per year.
In other words, Pittsburgh’s flat tax rate since 2015 is unusual. A boost of closer to 10% or (at most) 15% would catch the city up while taking a big bite out of the Gainey deficit.
Difficult cuts
But it wouldn’t resolve the deficit entirely: That will require a commitment to trimming city government.
We are encouraged by reporting by the Post-Gazette’s Hallie Lauer about a letter drafted by Council President Daniel Lavelle, which asks city department heads to submit a plan to cut expenses by 5% each. The letter demonstrates Lavelle’s and Council’s seriousness about considering all options. Cutting 5% across the board would yield about $24 million in savings.
Actually getting there, however, would prove all but impossible on such short notice. There simply isn’t enough to cut in non-personnel spending, which accounts for under 25% of everyday spending, and layoffs are very delicate — not just politically, but legally. With several unions representing city workers, each with their own layoff rules, getting personnel cuts across the line with three weeks to spare is unlikely to succeed. Further, layoffs must be considered carefully to avoid seriously damaging city services.
If Council is going to impose a tax increase on Pittsburgh property owners, it must aggressively pursue smart spending cuts. But it cannot solve Gainey’s mismanagement with cuts alone. Only a combination of taxes and cuts will put the city back on solid footing.
The only option
Council does face a legal complication in fixing the Gainey administration’s work: Amending it will bump up against a city rule meant to stymy runaway spending.
This may seem counterintuitive, but the problem is that Gainey underestimated expenses by so much that Council will likely have to increase those figures by more than the amount prescribed by law: Changes in the final budget “shall not exceed two (2) percent of the November proposed budget.” That 2% is only about $14 million, but Council will likely have to boost budgeted expenditures by much more than that to account for what the administration failed to include.
Luckily, that provision in city code begins with the phrase, “As a general rule.” The city’s Law Department and the Controller’s Office should consider Gainey’s false budget to be sufficient cause to violate this “general rule,” without setting a precedent that would undermine it in the long run. This is not an addition to a legitimate proposal, but a correction to an illegitimate proposal.
Council has three weeks until a hard deadline: Pittsburgh has never entered a new year without a new budget, and (unlike federal and state governments) there is no provision in law for keeping any government services open during a lapse. The only prudent course is to combine a modest tax increase with cuts to non-essential spending — an outcome required by Gainey’s mismanagement and Council’s timidity over the past four years.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.