“What does Remembrance Sunday mean for you? What is your message?” asked host Kate Garraway to Alec Penstone last Friday on Good Morning Britain, a popular morning show in the United Kingdom.
Mr. Penstone is a 100-year-old veteran of the Second World War who cleared mines on D-Day and is known in the U.K. as the nation’s oldest poppy-seller. Since the end of the First World War, red poppies have been a symbol of commemoration of military sacrifice, especially in the nations of the former British Empire. The U.K.’s Remembrance Day is its own descendent of Armistice Day, remembering the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month of 1918, when the Great War formally ended.
In the United States, this has become Veterans Day.
Mr. Penstone’s answer has reverberated around the globe. “My message is, I can see in my mind's eye those rows and rows of white stones and all the hundreds of my friends who gave their lives, for what? The country of today? No, I'm sorry — but the sacrifice wasn't worth the result of what it is now.”
Host Adil Ray pressed Mr. Penstone for specifics. “What we fought for was our freedom, but now it's a darn sight worse than when I fought for it,” the veteran responded.
What, exactly, Mr. Penstone meant by his lamentation is not clear. Many on the right have assumed he was referring to mass immigration and the perceived loss of Britain’s distinctive culture, an issue (somehow) even more contentious in the U.K. than in the U.S. Others have assumed he was referring to the rise of the far right itself, or perhaps the broader matter of culture-war divisions in British society, exemplified by the responses to his own remarks.
Yet few have questioned the underlying premise: that the United Kingdom of 2025 has failed in its duty to honor its veterans’ sacrifices not just through parades and financial benefits, but by continuing to thrive as a nation.
The sense of decline is far more pronounced in the U.K. than in the U.S. In the last 80 years Britain has lost a global empire and in the last 15 years its GDP has stagnated, while America’s has continued to grow.
However, Mr. Penstone’s candid remark has also struck a chord in America. A great many people, each for their own reasons, look around themselves and see a country that not lived up to their hopes and expectations. (We don’t need to rehash once again the dismal “right track/wrong track” or “trust in institutions” polling data.)
Remembrances of past glories, and the sacrifices that both were inspired by and sustained those glories, only seem to throw into sharper relief the malaise — to use the late President Jimmy Carter’s famous word — of the present moment.
Today, then, should be a day not just to talk about veterans’ care and funding and services, though this is essential, but to redouble our efforts to build a nation worthy of their sacrifices. That must include both spirited debate about what policies and leaders will make America stronger and a recognition that the parties to the debate are all Americans who share a desire to make this a nation worthy of its veterans’ sacrifices.
Let us think, then, about the day several decades from now when a veteran of today’s conflicts is being interviewed on whatever future media is in use, and work together to build a country he or she can be proud of both then and today.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.