Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato’s second budget demonstrates the creativity and discipline lacking in her City of Pittsburgh counterpart. After a significant tax increase for 2025, the proposed 2026 package largely avoids another tax hike while holding the line on spending, including saving a reported $15 million by reducing inefficiencies.

The Editorial Board has warned that Ms. Innamorato, both as a matter of policy and of electoral politics, should only get one bite at the tax-hike apple during this term in office. It is essential that county government live within its means, and not come to see taxpayers as a source of funds who can be squeezed time and again.

She and her team should be commended for producing a realistic budget that respects both the importance of well-funded services and the limitations of taxpayers, whose ability to spend and to save their own money is also crucial to the success of Allegheny County.

Still, there are troubling signs on the horizon — as Ms. Innamorato herself acknowledges in the statement introducing the budget: “The County’s current five-year outlook shows an increasing deficit as expenditures exceed revenues by a growing factor over time.” The county’s woefully underfunded pension system is another source of long-term financial stress.

Advertise with us

Given these realities, over the next year the Innamorato administration must consider deeper reforms to county government, in order to avoid tax increases not just now but in the years to come.

Buying time

The structural problem facing Allegheny County government is simply this: The cost of providing services is rising — especially due to an expanding need for social services, such as care for the homeless and for the elderly, where the lion’s share of spending is located — while tax receipts continue to stagnate due to stagnant growth and the collapse of commercial property values.

We continue to insist that a countywide real estate reassessment would at least stabilize the taxation system. This must be part of any solution for county finances going forward, but can’t help this particular budget.

While Ms. Innamorato’s budget does not solve or even address head-on this structural problem, it does buy time. Most notably, at the direction of county manager John Fournier, the administration reports it found $15 million in efficiencies by auditing its benefits system, streamlining staffing at the Kane Community Living Centers and rebidding outdated and expensive contracts, among other strategies.

This limited the proposed increase in overall spending to about $18 million, or 1.5%, which is well below inflation. However, this somewhat understates the spending bump, because last year’s budget set aside $23 million to pay for a reassessment that has yet to happen. Since that money is not in the 2026 budget, the total increase in regular spending is actually about $41 million, or a little over 3% — still in line with inflation.

Advertise with us

It may have been tempting for Ms. Innamorato to seek another tax hike, after County Council trimmed her proposed increase from 2.2 mils to 1.7 mils last year. But the nitty-gritty work of cost-saving ensured that wasn’t necessary.

Bearing fruit

We remain concerned, however, about the prospects for county finances. In particular, the county jail (an increase of $8.7 million), the Kane centers ($5.3 million) and the Department of Human Services ($8.3 million) account for the majority of the proposed spending increases. Altogether, these three budget lines alone add up to nearly half of the the county’s entire $1.2 billion operating budget.

The jail may be the biggest surprise. After years of decreasing population levels in the jail, a sharp uptick in incarceration — paired, the Innamorato administration points out, with a decrease in violent crime — has necessitated a sharp increase in spending.

This appears to challenge an argument both the administration and the Editorial Board have made for increasing spending for the Public Defender’s Office: that more effective representation for the huge majority of defendants who can’t afford a private attorney will result in people spending less unnecessary time in jail. Remember that the majority of ACJ inmates have not been convicted: They are awaiting trial.

However, we believe investments in indigent defense (for the second year in a row, Ms. Innamorato proposes boosting spending on public defense by nearly 10%) should be given more time to bear fruit. Further, the Public Defender’s Office endured turmoil this year before, during and after the firing of its chief, Lena Bryan-Henderson, who was the subject of a human resources investigation over unspecified misconduct.

Advertise with us

In the long run, we continue to believe that a better funded, better functioning indigent defense system will result in more just outcomes — and less use of incarceration.

Darkening skies

Ms. Innamorato’s budget is a disciplined response to a difficult situation. But funding the county’s government is only going to get more difficult, and the required decisions more challenging to make.

In the coming years, resolving inefficiencies and improving vendor deals will no longer suffice. Either the county is going to have to ask for a lot more money from taxpayers, again, to keep things going as they are, or its leaders will have to rethink its government in a much more substantial way.

It isn’t fair to lay the burden on taxpayers, many of whom are also staring down tax increases from their municipalities and school districts. We’d like to see the Innamorato administration, as well as Corey O’Connor’s successor as County Controller, undertake a deep study of county government in the coming year — especially in the area of social services, which account for so much of county spending.

This will entail hard choices about what the county must fund, and what does not; what areas can make do with less; whether structures that have been in place for decades should remain in place; and even what areas of county responsibility could be handled by, or at least shared with, the private sector.

The year 2026 will be an inflection point in Allegheny County history. Ms. Innamorato will decide which way it goes.