The Allegheny County property assessment and taxation system continues to be a slow-motion disaster. Only County Executive Sara Innamorato can stop the situation from degrading further, by finally following through on her campaign pledge to call a countywide reassessment.
Last week, the deadline for appeals for the coming tax year passed, with about 6,000 filed. Hearings on these appeals, many of which will involve further reductions in the value of commercial properties, began this Monday. The results of these cases will continue to erode the tax bases of every municipality and school district in Allegheny County.
We understand the reasons to delay. There is good reason to have some kind of taxpayer protection legislation in place to ensure low- and fixed-income homeowners aren’t crushed by a huge spike in their assessed values.
There is good reason to put in place a permanent reform of the assessment and taxation system, such as regular three- or five-year reassessments, as part of this assessment cycle. There is good reason to use this year’s scheduled (though delayed) convening of the Government Review Commission to study the system and suggest other reforms.
Yet the system is collapsing at this moment. As we have previously stated, a countywide reassessment is like an earthquake along a fault line on which pressure has been building for many years. The longer between quakes, the greater the tension that has built up, and therefore the more damage the inevitable earthquake will cause.
The desire for taxpayer protections and long-term reforms must be weighed against the risks of delay. Besides the declines in commercial property values, which necessitates either cutting costs or raising taxes while shifting the tax burden onto residents, a delayed reassessment only worsens the existing injustice in the system, as similar properties are assessed at more widely divergent values.
This is particularly troubling for residents in communities where property values haven’t increased appreciably since the last full reassessment in 2012. They are paying a disproportionate amount in taxes, while many households in high-growth communities continue to pay as if it were still 2012.
Meanwhile, the so-called “newcomers tax,” in which school districts or municipalities challenge an out-of-date assessment based on a high sale price, has resulted in similar homes on the same street being assessed, and therefore taxed, at values hundreds of thousands of dollars apart.
There is blame to go around for the reassessment delay. While we believe Ms. Innamorato can and should act with more urgency, County Council has hardly helped.
On key areas to lay a firmer foundation for a reassessment, from a bill to protect long-time homeowners with low or fixed incomes from a huge assessment-and-tax hike to appointing members of the Government Review Commission — which is bound by the county charter to meet this year — Ms. Innamorato cannot act alone. And council has not behaved as if there’s any reason to hurry.
Reassessments are politically unpopular, and those in office when a reassessment is called and carried out are likely to pay a political cost. But these men and women chose to run for office, and the purpose of holding office is to do right by the people of Allegheny County — not to try to hold office forever.
Part of that responsibility is resetting the county’s property assessment system, because further delay — more build up of the tension — will only cause more pain to more people.
It’s only going to get worse. Getting reassessment done quickly, and done right, must be county government’s top priority.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.