The announcement of a major expansion of Highmark Stadium, long-time home of the Pittsburgh Riverhounds men’s soccer franchise and now the Riveters women’s team as well, is the biggest step yet in Pittsburgh’s quest to become a true four-sport city. The entire region should be pleased that the facility on the picturesque South Shore, which a BBC reporter once called “the most beautiful stadium I’ve ever seen,” is slated to triple in capacity to 15,000 people — and leave the river-and-city view intact.

Besides hosting dozens of soccer matches a year, the expanded Highmark Stadium will also fill a void within city limits for large outdoor concerts between Stage AE’s 5,500-person capacity and PNC Park’s 39,000. We hope and expect that bringing more people to the southern side of the Monongahela will induce renewed development at Station Square, a site with huge potential whose luster has faded since the COVID pandemic.

Yet the plans for the soccer stadium also raise thorny questions about the use of public funds for athletic facilities.

Part of Pittsburgh

On this point, the coming negotiations over Highmark will serve as an appetizer to a rapidly approaching main course: the expiration of the leases between the Steelers and Pirates on the one hand and the Sports and Exhibition Authority (SEA) on the other. Public authorities must begin planning now for what promises to be a bruising battle in the years to come.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Riverhounds were founded in 1998 — coincidentally, the same year the deal was struck to fund Acrisure Stadium and PNC Park — and the team played its first home games at Bethel Park High School’s stadium. In 2007 the team went on hiatus, before returning the next year at Chartiers Valley.

Then in 2013, the Riverhounds settled into Highmark Stadium under the new ownership of Connellsville businessman Tuffy Shallenberger, who also owns the stadium and some adjacent parking lots. This gave the franchise a feeling of permanency it had always lacked, finally making growth into a community institution possible.

The team competes in USL Championship, which is currently the highest level of the United Soccer League. USL Championship is considered a second-level league, below Major League Soccer. USL, however, is planning to launch a new league in 2028, tentatively named Division One, which would join MLS as a top-level league — which means its teams would compete in international club competitions.

The Highmark Stadium expansion will bring the facility to the minimum capacity for a team in the new USL format.

The next level

The excitement generated by this project mustn’t blind Pittsburghers to the financial and political reality that it will require help from public sources. This is further complicated by the fact that Highmark Stadium and some of its surroundings, unlike the city’s Big Three sports facilities, are privately owned.

Advertise with us

This means, on the one hand, that the Riverhounds generate property tax revenues that Acrisure Stadium, PNC Park and PPG Paints Arena do not. But it also means that all profits accrue to the team’s owner. While almost all revenues at SEA-owned sites also go to the teams, there are some provisions for public benefit. For instance, the Steelers must return 15% of non-sporting-event revenues to the Authority, and the city and the county have the right to use the stadium for community events three times a year (excluding football season).

Even so, we would support some public assistance to the Riverhounds project as an investment in a growing community asset that needs a boost to get to the next level — in contrast to the Steelers and the Pirates, which are established billion-dollar corporations. Further, the Highmark project can be supported with existing programs, just like other privately owned development projects with long-term public benefits.

Specifically, the team has already received funds from the state’s Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program (RACP) to plan the stadium expansion; a bipartisan coalition of regional legislators should advocate in Harrisburg for a more substantial infusion. We would also support a tax abatement scheme, like those offered for Downtown development through the Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance Act (LERTA), which would facilitate financing the project, while bringing in more taxes in the long run.

One fly in the ointment: In researching Highmark Stadium’s tax status, the Editorial Board discovered that Mr. Shallenberger owed over $300,000 in back property taxes to Allegheny County and the City of Pittsburgh for the stadium and parking lots.

We reached out to the team, which described the most of the balance as an oversight it is correcting, while some of the city taxes dating back several years are the subject of a dispute between the team and the city. We expect all this to be sorted out before any requests for public assistance are made.

Advertise with us

Careful considerations

This discussion necessarily raises the question of the Acrisure and PNC leases with the SEA, which expire in 2031. That may sound far away, but conversations about successor agreements have been quietly happening for some time. Some numbers that have been floated are $900 million for upgrades to the football stadium and $600 million for the baseball stadium.

These informal, ad hoc conversations benefit the teams, because they can maneuver pieces quietly into place on their own terms. It would be better for a commission or working group to have formal discussions. Mayor Ed Gainey’s successor, likely Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, should team up with County Executive Sara Innamorato to convene such a group, including team executives, public officials, the SEA and other stakeholders.

Sports help define Pittsburgh’s identity, and the emergence of a fourth professional powerhouse would only add to the city’s character and appeal. While the Riverhounds can use a little public help to become established in Pittsburgh, the argument for massive taxpayer subsidies is less clear for profitable corporate behemoths.