President Donald Trump’s assertion of control over public safety in Washington, D.C., is alarming both in itself and as a potential forerunner to similar actions targeting other U.S. cities, including Pittsburgh. His moves stretch the meaning of “emergency” beyond reason, and are very unlikely to actually improve the conditions of low-level disorder — or certainly the largely imaginary problem of violent criminality — which they are ostensibly designed to combat.

Mr. Trump is asserting his right under federal law to take control of Washington’s city police force, while supplementing nighttime patrols with over 100 FBI agents and deploying 800 National Guard soldiers to the District.

This is yet another example of a presidential action before which several people, including especially cabinet officials, had the opportunity and the duty to say, “no.” We urge Congress, which can reverse White House orders in the federal district, to stand up to Mr. Trump by restoring local control to Washington, because there is no emergency to justify suspending it.

The abuse of emergency powers is, historically, where those in power most aggressively erode democratic norms.

Advertise with us

Power move

The problems facing the District of Columbia are similar to those facing cities across the country — but its legal-political situation is unique, which allows Mr. Trump to run experiments there that would be more difficult or impossible elsewhere.

As the United States’ only federal district, Washington was under the direct control of Congress for nearly two centuries, until that legislature adopted local home rule in 1973. Still, the federal government has a unique role in governing the district in which it is headquartered. Among those privileges is the president’s prerogative to seize control of the Metropolitan Police Department for up to 30 days during “special conditions of an emergency nature.”

The District of Columbia’s National Guard is also under the president’s direct authority. This means his deployment faces none of the legal challenges that followed his federalization of California’s National Guard to suppress deportation protests in Los Angeles earlier this year.

These measures are meant to give the president resources to support and defend the seat of government in times of national distress. Five years ago, when Mr. Trump deployed an excessive 5,000 guardsmen to the capital during Black Lives Matter protests, at least he had the fig leaf of an emergent and unpredictable situation. But now, the day-to-day conditions in Washington are hardly different than in any other city in America.

There is crime, but there is no emergency. The city is in no danger. Which is what makes the president’s moves so disturbing, both for Washington and for all American cities.

Advertise with us

Manufactured crisis

Mr. Trump’s seizure of emergency powers in the nation’s capital is based on the perception, shared by many Americans, of urban insecurity, which manifests in two ways. One version is simply false, while the other is partly right — but certainly not solvable by military force.

First, despite Mr. Trump’s portrait of Mad Max-style chaos in D.C. and elsewhere, official statistics are in agreement that violent crime is at a historic low in American cities. In Washington, for instance, after an increase in crime during and after the pandemic, figures hit 30-year lows in 2024. And this year, violent crime has declined another one-fourth from that historic low.

Cities across the country, including Pittsburgh, have seen similar drops in violent crime, especially homicides.

Second, Mr. Trump is identifying, and exploiting, another kind of unease: a sense that cities suffer a general, low-level disorder. This refers to everything from transit fare evasion to noticeable increases in unsheltered homelessness to shoplifting and car break-ins.

The perception is based to some degree on real conditions — homelessness, for instance, is undoubtedly up across the nation — but this is more dysfunction than disorder. This is amplified by social media applications, which feed users endless images of disorderly behavior, from bodega robberies to brawling children to obscene public acts. Unscrupulous politicians exploit this to generate a feeling of immediate crisis that is wildly exaggerated from reality, and use that feeling to justify expanding their power.

Advertise with us

The causes of the dysfunction are deep and varied: the closure of residential mental health institutions without adequate replacements; the collapse of an economic order that broadly provided family-sustaining wages; the erosion of the anchor of family and community, and their replacement by digital facsimiles; the emergence of new kinds of recreational drugs.

None of these are addressed by the FBI and the National Guard. Occupying Washington, D.C., may give the illusion of “order” being restored, but is not creating real order. It is brutalizing people who need help and degrading Americans’ relationship with their own government.

Real solutions

The worst-case scenario is that Mr. Trump sees his Washington operation as a trial run for deploying the National Guard to other cities on similar pretexts.

He cannot legally seize local police forces beyond the federal district. But in California he has established a precedent for overriding state control of state guardsmen. Whether he can extend that precedent will depend on the outcome of an ongoing lawsuit challenging his California deployment.

The pretextual “emergency” to deal with “disorder” is a mainstay of the erosion and eventual collapse of democratic norms, and their replacement with subservience to a government that uses visible force — such as soldiers patrolling cities — to establish rule by fear.

Advertise with us

America certainly has broad problems in urban governance, which manifest themselves in Washington, Pittsburgh and elsewhere. Achieving solutions will require addressing the underlying conditions that lead to despair and dysfunction, as well as strategic responses to the particularities of each city. Armed forces directed from the capital are just about the least likely way to improve America’s cities in a sustainable way.

Congress should protect our system of dispersed government by rejecting Mr. Trump’s “emergency” claim in Washington. Failing that, the operation must end at the legal limit of 30 days. Governors should prepare to defend their legal authority over their states’ National Guards and mayors over their cities.

The military occupation of American cities must never be tolerated.