If Downtown Pittsburgh had a Main Street, it would be Liberty Avenue. The wide boulevard provides a direct connection between the Point (and the interstates that meet there) and the Strip District; it skirts Market Square and the David L. Lawrence Convention Center while forming an integral part of the Cultural District; and it touches two subway stations while it prepares to host a key portion of PRT’s University Line rapid bus transit system.

In the coming months and years, getting Liberty right will be one of the most important parts of getting the Golden Triangle right — reimagining it as a safe, dynamic and complete neighborhood, as opposed to a collection of aging office towers.

The recent announcement of a grocery store coming to Liberty Avenue, a long-awaited and much-anticipated Downtown amenity, gives the corridor a shot in the arm. The Golden Triangle’s most important corridor will require sustained and strategic attention, but it could become a main catalyst for Downtown revitalization.

But due to inattentiveness and lack of foresight among political leaders here and in Harrisburg, the boulevard is also threatened by nuisance property uses — specifically so-called “smoke” and “vape shops,” traditionally known as “head shops” — that attract and encourage anti-social and illegal activity.

Advertise with us

This threatens a return to the notoriously seedy past of Liberty Avenue, crowding out everyone from arts-district visitors to legitimate retailers and potential residents.

The opportunity

Pittsburgh’s central business district is a collection of corridors, each with its own character. There’s Smithfield, the historic retail district slowly recovering from becoming the epicenter of the region’s homelessness crisis. There’s Grant, the traditional locus of political and corporate power. And there’s Penn, heart of the Cultural District and now, especially after smart road-dieting and streetscaping, a premier dining destination.

Then there’s Liberty, one block south of Penn. Starting at the Point, it’s a corporate canyon: Gateway Center, Fifth Avenue Place, EQT Building, Two PNC Plaza, K&L Gates. Then between Sixth and Wood streets it transitions to a cultural and historic district: the Harris Theater, the August Wilson Center, the Triangle Building, numerous well-preserved turn-of-the century walk-ups. And finally, Liberty comes to the Convention Center and Penn Station area before diving into the Strip District.

It’s one of the most common welcoming points for newcomers from the airport, and it contains examples of nearly everything the city has to offer. It also has a high concentration of buildings of just the right size and age to be suitable for residential conversions. It could and should extend the success of the Penn corridor — an expansion of the beachhead of effective development along the Allegheny River.

The Well Well Market, Downtown’s first full grocery store in decades, should serve as an anchor on the 800 block. Downtown advocates and stakeholders, including the Downtown Neighbors Alliance, deserve praise for securing this deal, which will hopefully lead to opening within the next year.

Advertise with us

The threat

The biggest threat to this progress is one that is shared by business districts all across Pennsylvania: the proliferation of gaudy “smoke” or “vape” storefronts that operate in (at best) a legal gray area. There are four within a few blocks on Liberty alone.

These businesses ostensibly sell legal-in-Pennsylvania products like Delta-8, a derivative of the hemp plant with similar properties to the THC found in cannabis. While some shops operate completely within the law, multiple sources with knowledge of the situation Downtown describe transactions that clearly violate it, from the minor — “loosie” cigarettes and individual cans of beer — to the more serious — drug-free human urine for skirting drug tests and unquestionably illegal narcotics.

Besides being aesthetically discordant — you can recognize these shops from their blazing LED signage — these businesses tend to attract anti-social behaviors, such as public intoxication. They are particularly popular in downtowns because of the anonymity offered by density. And landlords favor them because they’re lucrative, so they easily pay even inflated rents.

Meanwhile, these establishments, and the activities they facilitate, degrade overall livability and render nearby storefronts less marketable. At a critical mass, they crowd out other property uses — not unlike the old Liberty Avenue.

The solution

To some degree, local authorities are hamstrung in dealing with vape shops because the regulations that govern their products are drawn up in Harrisburg. It is possible that a clearer regulatory structure for marijuana and other THC products would undercut the existing head shop market.

Advertise with us

But Pittsburgh’s hands are far from tied: City officials already have tools to rein in these businesses, but they have declined to use them. Further, City Council can take action to further restrict nuisance property uses.

The northern side of Liberty, for instance, is part of the Penn-Liberty Historic District, which includes strict rules meant to preserve its character. Vape shops within the district brazenly violate at least the signage rules, and perhaps more — yet the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections has failed to take action.

The city also has a “disruptive property” ordinance, which can be triggered after either a single on-site felony or three citations for disruptive activity. While this is typically used against bars, shops that facilitate anti-social and illegal behavior should also be cited. Properties designated “disruptive” can be charged for law enforcement services, radically altering the financial incentives for business owners and landlords.

Then there’s zoning: Cities across the country have used land-use laws to restrict head shops. Options include minimum distances from schools, parks, libraries or each other, which could radically limit options in dense commercial districts. Onerous city permitting rules could also rein them in.

Liberty Avenue is a tremendous opportunity to expand on successful Downtown efforts in a way that could spark transformation across the Golden Triangle. Private-sector stakeholders have stepped up to the plate, including securing Downtown’s holy grail: a grocery store.

Now, the public sector must do its part to ensure this essential corridor, and the people who visit and live there, can thrive.