The recent announcement of BNY Mellon’s final retreat from its namesake tower should serve as the most alarming in a series of warning bells indicating that the iconic skyscraper, Pittsburgh’s second-tallest, is not viable in its current form. Devising a solution, in some form or another, for the building and the land it sits on must be a top priority for Mayor Ed Gainey and his presumptive successor, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor.
Here’s the tale of the tape. The 55-story BNY Mellon Center includes a whopping 1.6 million square feet of office space. The carrying costs on the building — that is, the cost to the owner, MetLife, simply to keep it from freezing in winter and falling into disrepair — is about $10 per square foot, or $16 million per year.
Meanwhile, the cost to tear down the skyscraper, which is complicated by the presence of a subway station beneath the structure, is hard to pin down, but one source estimated about $40 million. That’s two-and-a-half years’ worth of carrying costs, which means it quickly becomes economical for the owner to tear it down.
The timeframe is tight. BNY Mellon plans to vacate the building, on which it has a master lease for the entire 1.6 million square feet, by 2027. The corporate banking giant will move all its local employees into its Ross Street building, which is still the company’s biggest employment center in North America. One silver lining to this story: BNY Mellon’s retreat from the tower is not a retreat from Pittsburgh, but a reallocation of resources in a post-pandemic work-from-home world.
The master lease, meanwhile, expires in 2028. The Post-Gazette’s Madaleine Rubin has reported that the skyscraper’s remaining tenants, which are subleasing from the bank, are in the process of seeking new space or are already moving. That means the tower will likely be empty within 18 months, while MetLife will still be collecting rent from BNY Mellon for another year or so. Then, the crisis begins in earnest.
But there’s no reason to wait: Devising and executing a creative solution for the massive building will take years.
The only fully office-based solution would be a corporate whale of the size Pittsburgh is very unlikely to attract. And the building is far too big to consider for a residential conversion — though the 17-story tower attached to the building’s southern corner offers intriguing possibilities for a separate solution.
Any plausible plan to preserve the tower will involve a diversity of uses, must fill all or nearly all the building to avoid ongoing upkeep costs for unused space, and even still will be very unlikely to be commercially viable: That is, it would probably require public or nonprofit partnerships, and ongoing funding, to be sustainable.
Any serious planning for the future of the BNY Mellon Center must also consider the benefits of tearing it down, in part or in whole. While this would be a blow to Pittsburgh’s morale, it could be turned into an opportunity for renewal, opening an entire city block for development tailored to the present moment, rather than to the needs of corporations four decades ago.
The city, perhaps in concert with the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership and with foundation funding, should appoint a single individual whose sole job is to rally stakeholders and generate solutions for the skyscraper. How this saga goes will be a turning point for Downtown — either toward transformation and renewal, or toward anxiety and decline.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.