Pittsburgh needs a rental registry with reasonable landlord fees and regular inspections, consistent with cities across Pennsylvania and the United States, to ensure the safety of the city’s growing population of renters. The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has been consistently skeptical of attempts by landlord groups to stymy the city’s registry legislation based on legal technicalities.

Yet, these groups have been consistently successful. And now, new information shows that the Gainey administration’s strategy of announcing a “voluntary” program, and giving the false impression the registry had been fully implemented, has backfired — and may make successfully defending the policy more difficult.

The Gainey campaign represented the registry as a fait accompli. Language used in campaign materials included claims that Mr. Gainey had “made the rental registry a reality” and that he had “relaunched a rental registry.”

What neither the campaign nor the administration ever directly acknowledged is that the city had been enjoined from enforcing the registry by an Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas judge on Dec. 2 of last year. That injunction expired on Feb. 1, but the city was still litigating its ability to enforce the registry throughout the primary election season.

Advertise with us

It didn’t go well.

The Gainey administration officially “launched” the rental registry on Dec. 19, 2024 — about two weeks after the injunction — but amid the stern language on the city’s website about enforcement was this line: “Until [June 1, 2025], compliance with this program is voluntary.”

Needless to say, very few property owners complied. Two months later, of the tens of thousands of rental units in the city, only 130 had voluntarily joined the registry and inspection program.

Meanwhile, landlord associations were strongly contesting the city’s public representation of the program in court, claiming that the threat of enforcement on June 1 clearly violated the Dec. 2 injunction. In early April, the two sides were ordered by a judge to settle at least some of their differences: While the text of that agreement is not in the public record, just days later the city updated its website, deleting the June 1 enforcement deadline.

Then, just last Wednesday, the city’s request to put that deadline back into force was shot down by the court, which ruled that the city must “make clear [the registry] is voluntary” and must not make any “threats of sanctions.” So enforcement is, once again, on hold indefinitely. While the city’s website has been scrubbed of the deadline and threats, the published “rules and regulations” of the program still reference the June 1 enforcement date.

Advertise with us

Despite these setbacks, the Gainey campaign continued to represent the registry as a completed, successful program, based on the ploy of the “voluntary” program initiated by the administration. But in reality they’d gotten no farther than previous mayors.

We continue to believe that, on the merits, the Gainey administration is in the right. The registry is good policy, and the proposed fees are more than reasonable; in fact, they’re much lower than those in many smaller cities in Pennsylvania. While the registry will impose costs in the form of fees and required upgrades of rental units, which will be in part passed on to renters, the health and safety benefits will be worth it.

But the tactics deployed by the Gainey administration and campaign, which together seemingly tried to boost the mayor’s reelection chances by giving a false impression of the registry’s implementation, ended up resulting in unnecessary and damaging legal setbacks.

We hope the administration will prevail in this fight. But it has made its own job harder than it needs to be.