A new first-time homebuyer assistance program from Allegheny County is a welcome counterpart to existing programs in the City of Pittsburgh. Facilitating home-ownership is one of the best ways to enhance social and economic stability for families, while building generational wealth. The program, called 1st Home Allegheny, is an excellent use of the resources of the county’s Residential Finance Authority by County Executive Sara Innamorato.

Increases in the price of housing, both rental and crucially for-sale, have far out-paced median wage growth over the past several years. This has combined with increases in the cost of living to make the traditional path to middle-class security, homeownership, out of reach for many everyday people, even in a low-cost region like southwestern Pennsylvania. It’s harder to save up for a down payment, and it’s harder to make a commitment to a mortgage with high interest rates for an expensive house.

For instance, until a decade ago houses in Pittsburgh’s working- and middle-class neighborhoods almost never sold for more than $200,000, and typically went for $150,000 or less. Now in those same neighborhoods it’s all but impossible to find homes under $200,000, and $250,000 and $300,000 is more common.

The ideal down payment of 20% on a $250,000 home is $50,000. That’s almost two-thirds of the median household income — before taxes — for Allegheny County residents. Further, most first-time homebuyers are younger, perhaps with young children or looking to start a family, which means their median income is much lower. They have to stash away about an entire year’s income just to get their foot in the door. Many can’t.

Advertise with us

It’s an unsustainable situation. The 1st Home Allegheny program is meant to help first-time homebuyers clear that initial hurdle.

The program offers forgivable loans — which might also be called conditional grants — of either $10,000 or $45,000 for prospective first-time homebuyers to use for closing costs and down payment assistance. The smaller amount is available to “middle-income” buyers, which cashes out to $86,480 for an individual and about $124,000 for a family of four. The larger amount is available to “moderate-income” buyers, which means about $60,000 for an individual and $86,000 for a family of four.

The interest-free loans are forgiven after six years, as long the the buyer remains an owner-occupant of the home for that long. This incentivizes neighborhood stability.

The county program charts a smart middle course between two Urban Redevelopment Authority programs available in the City of Pittsburgh. (1st Home Allegheny is only for non-city properties.) The Down Payment and Closing Cost Assistance Program offers modest amounts of up to $5,000 to $7,500, depending on income, in a form of interest-free deferred loans borrowers only start repaying after several years.

OwnPGH offers grants of up to $90,000 for first-time homebuyer under 80% area median income. Buyers must get prequalified with a participating bank to participate. This program has become a flashpoint in the mayoral primary, with Mayor Ed Gainey and challenger Corey O’Connor sparring over credit for it. The concept began under former Mayor Bill Peduto, who set aside federal pandemic relief funds for it. OwnPGH was then funded for the first time during the Gainey administration, but at lower levels than Mr. Peduto had proposed.

Advertise with us

Importantly, both OwnPGH and 1st Home Allegheny include required financial counseling services, in order to minimize the chance owning a home becomes a financial curse rather than a blessing.

We applaud Ms. Innamorato for extending homeownership support across Allegheny County. More emphasis on for-sale housing affordability, including incentivizing new construction, will widen the currently far-too-narrow path to middle-class stability for Pittsburgh families.