Last week, the Fraternal Order of Police — the city’s police union — terminated contract negotiations with the Gainey administration over five-year-old anti-police social media posts by Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank. That wasn’t fair to Ms. Frank, whose suitability for the job of head negotiator should depend on her conduct, not views expressed online in 2020.
Ms. Frank’s response, in which she stated that working for the city and with its public safety department resulted in an “evolution” of her views on policing, should be taken at face value. It’s far from uncommon for people with harsh views in the abstract to soften those views once they see and experience the system they’re criticizing from the inside.
However, Ms. Frank’s specific explanation for her change of heart — the Gainey administration’s commitment to “community policing” — is pure campaign rhetoric, with no relation to reality. The Bureau has far fewer community resources than it did four years ago, and its primary “civilianization” initiative — so-called “neighborhood ambassadors” — has been stillborn.
Due to the limitations imposed by the city’s police staffing crisis, the bureau is far less community-oriented than it has been in many years.
Mr. Gainey inherited a police force with Neighborhood Resource Officers and Community Resource Officers, which each had slightly different everyday tasks, but the same purpose: representing the police to the community in non-law-enforcement situations, such as coffee shop chess matches with kids or neighborhood meetings. Those programs have been gutted.
Former Chief Larry Scirotto — the longest-tenured of the record five Pittsburgh chiefs in the last three years — declared that community policing programs were no longer needed because every officer should be a community officer. But when everyone specializes, no one does. and community interaction with police officers has plummeted.
The real reason for gutting the NRO and CRO programs, of course, was the bureau’s historic staffing crisis: There are fewer than 700 officers available for a city that until recently budgeted for 900. And the proof of the necessity of more officers is right in the massively over-budget overtime the city is paying to its officers.
Zone 6, for instance, which includes the entire West End and much of the South Hills neighborhoods, has 37 officers available for all shifts. Until recently, 90 was considered full staffing.
Mr. Scirotto proposed civilian “neighborhood ambassadors” as a stopgap: These unsworn public safety officers would walk main street beats and call in resources, whether cops or EMS or social workers, as needed. In fact, this program still comes up in Mr. Gainey’s descriptions of his community safety initiatives. But it never actually got off the ground.
The few ambassadors that have been hired and trained are working desk duty. That’s because the original plan included them performing duties that are defined as police work in the city’s contract with the FOP. The two sides came to an agreement about what the ambassadors can and can’t do — but the city still hasn’t figured out how to honor that agreement while still deploying them to the streets. Neighborhoods that have been promised these ambassadors are still waiting.
Resurrecting five-year-old social media posts wasn’t fair to Ms. Frank — it’s her performance that counts, not her 2020 views.
But her description of “community policing” is also fanciful. During her, and Mr. Gainey’s, tenure in the city, community-based policing has only gone backward.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.