Last December, when a tragic fire ripped through the decrepit Maple Ridge Apartments in the city’s East Hills neighborhood, killing two-year-old Praise Lemons, Mayor Ed Gainey immediately blamed the complex’s out-of-town owner, while claiming the city was working hard to figure out exactly who was in charge.
We now know, after reporting by the Post-Gazette’s Stephana Oceanu and Mike Wereschagin, that Mr. Gainey was either lying about the city’s long-term relationship with Seattle-based Vitus Group LLC, or was woefully ignorant about the workings of the government he runs. Pittsburgh, it turns out, had been working for years with Vitus’s leaders in a collaborative effort to secure funding to renovate Maple Ridge while keeping it affordable.
In fact, it’s exactly the kind of public-private collaboration that is essential to delivering services, including affordable housing, to vulnerable people in Pittsburgh. It’s a reality that confounds the simplistic narrative of the greedy private sector against the pure public sector, peddled by Mr. Gainey and his allies. The only way to get things done is to work together, so long as there is mutual good faith and shared goals that can be achieved.
But the relationship between the city and Vitus is also an example of how laborious it is to navigate the bureaucracies that deliver resources. It’s clear that conditions deteriorated for years at Maple Ridge in part because Vitus was counting on funding that never materialized. That doesn’t absolve the company, which took on a responsibility to its tenants by virtue of buying the property, but it does complicate the narrative.
A tragedy years in the making
The Maple Ridge Apartments are located in East Hills, a peninsula of the City of Pittsburgh surrounded on three sides by the suburbs of Penn Hills and Wilkinsburg. The neighborhood is dominated by several large rental complexes, and is easily forgotten by city residents — and city officials.
Investigators have yet to release the cause of the fire that broke out in Maple Ridge on the night of December 27, just two days after Christmas, but we do know the terrible result: Praise Lemons, just two years old, lost her life.
Yet that was neither the beginning nor the end of the problems at the complex. For years, city inspectors had found everything from vermin infestations to malfunctioning heating systems. In fact, less than a month after the deadly fire, other Maple Ridge buildings lost heat, forcing residents to find temporary housing.
On its face, it’s another example of a neglectful property company cruelly allowing its tenants to suffer unsafe and unhealthy shelter. That’s certainly how Mr. Gainey framed it after the fire, and then in a video posted on X during the January heating crisis: “To the owners of Maple Ridge Apartments, let me make it clear: This is not acceptable, and I call upon you to step up and do what is right to repair your properties.”
He’s right, at least in part: Vitus Group bought Maple Ridge with eyes wide open, and has a responsibility to provide dignified shelter to its tenants. But it’s also much more complicated, because Mr. Gainey’s own government had promised to help the company fulfill its responsibilities — and didn’t deliver.
Failure to deliver
The Gainey administration’s relationship with Vitus goes back to early 2022, according to the Post-Gazette report. That’s when Urban Redevelopment Authority board chair, and now Mr. Gainey’s chief of staff, Kyle Chintalapalli arranged to issue $17 million in tax-exempt bonds to support a loan fund, from which Vitus would take out roughly $9 million to renovate Maple Ridge. It’s an example of how collaborative governance should work.
But that’s only step one of the convoluted affording housing financing process. Once the URA agreed to the bond issue, then Vitus could apply to the state for a federal Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC). And only once the LIHTC comes through does the URA actually float the bond, filling the loan fund from which Vitus can access money to perform its renovations. It’s a years-long process, during which people living in deplorable conditions are stuck.
But the LIHTC hasn’t come through. In practice, the municipal government, with the support of the local state senator and/or representative, appeals to Harrisburg on behalf of a tax credit applicant, and the application is approved. But despite Pittsburgh advocating for and receiving a record six LIHTCs in the 2024 funding cycle, Vitus-owned Maple Ridge wasn’t among them.
Whether this was because the Gainey administration didn’t prioritize the Vitus bid, or because Vitus didn’t fulfill its duties in some way, is not known at this time. What’s clear is that the public-private collaboration broke down, and the people of Maple Ridge suffered for it.
Competent leadership, not grandstanding
And so there are two main takeaways from the Maple Ridge crisis. First, the procedures by which governments and corporations fund affordable housing is byzantine and fundamentally broken. Even in the best case scenario, the URA would have floated a bond, to fill a loan fund, which Vitus could use to begin renovations, only in late 2024 — two years after the company purchased the complex. That’s not fast enough for residents. Further, it discourages trustworthy corporations from investing in affordable housing, leaving a void often filled by grifters and con-men.
Second, the only way to navigate these systems effectively is through public-private cooperation. There’s no doubt that Vitus could have and should have done more for Maple Ridge while waiting for its funds, but the city essentially lured the company to East Hills with the promise of an LIHTC. Further, the city had two years in which to lean on Vitus to improve conditions at the complex, but instead Mr. Gainey resorted to after-the-fact grandstanding. And outright deception.
Neither of these helped the residents of Maple Ridge. What they needed, but didn’t get, was competent leadership.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.