Health insurance companies in Pennsylvania and around the country are denying too many claims. In fact, it’s clear from the rates at which appeals of claim denials succeed that at least some companies are intentionally denying more claims than they should, knowing that few of their members have the time and energy to fight them.

In Pennsylvania, a new bipartisan bill, introduced by state Rep. Arvind Venkat, D-McCandless — himself a medical doctor — is seeking to make these appeal-success rates public, and to punish companies with ridiculous high ones. It’s a common-sense rule to rein in a confounding private system that serves a public purpose — but only when it’s operated fairly.

In the convoluted American health care system, access to care is generally controlled by private insurance companies. Because it would be economically impossible to provide all the health care services everyone thinks they need, a rationing system is necessary.

In state-run systems like the United Kingdom’s National Health Service, that rationing is controlled by the state, and is meant to be based on objective health criteria, rather than ability to pay. In theory, this means a system with fewer inducements to deny needed care. In practice, due to lackluster leadership and insufficient funding, this model also results in long waits for care that are effectively temporary denials.

Advertise with us

The American system rolls several systems into one. Medicaid and Medicare function as single-payer government-run insurance schemes. Private insurance is primarily tied to employers, with the Affordable Care Act marketplace picking up the slack. The system for deciding what care to provide and how to price it is opaque and varies confusingly between companies. Everyone knows it’s a mess, one in which some people are denied care they need, but no one can agree what to do about it.

The private health care system rations care, and that is necessary to fulfilling its public purpose. Companies enforce rules, such as pre-authorization, that are meant to limit unnecessary care, in order to spend its scarce resources (and the scarce time of providers) on care that people genuinely need. In other words, health insurer rules are necessary, and denying claims and care is part of how they serve a public purpose.

But most insurers are also for-profit enterprises, which means they also have an incentive to deny more care and claims than they need to, in order to avoid paying for them. This is where the commonwealth can step in.

Faced with going to war with their insurers, most people don’t bother to appeal denials: Fewer than 1% do so. That’s why the Shapiro administration empowered the Pennsylvania Insurance Department to perform an “independent external review” of insurance company decisions. In January, the administration announced that more than half of 259 appealed denials were reversed. This strongly suggests that companies are carelessly, and possibly knowingly, denying legitimate claims.

The Venkat bill would require that insurers make their denial-appeal success rates public — covering both internal and external reviews — which would induce competition among firms to avoid having the highest rates, and signal to everyday people that their appeals might be likely to succeed. Second, the bill would fine insurers whose denials are successfully appealed more than 50% of the time, up to $250,000 per denial above that threshold. That’s enough to incentivize real change.

In the American system, private health insurers’ rules serve a real purpose. But when those rules are abused by the very companies that make them, that public purpose is replaced by private profit. That’s where the state needs to set things right.