Is unsheltered homelessness in Pittsburgh solved? Mayor Ed Gainey would like everyone to think so. On campaign materials, the incumbent — who is suddenly in a tough battle for re-election against Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor — is saying that he “found opportunities for all unhoused people to come indoors, restoring the city’s trails to their intended use while creating real housing options for all.”
That’s a confident claim that doesn’t live up to the much more complicated reality.
The Allegheny County Department of Human Services (DHS), with some support from the City of Pittsburgh, has developed a much more comprehensive winter shelter system, which has ensured that all, or almost all, unhoused people who would like to come indoors overnight are able to do so. That is a genuine improvement from last winter, and city and especially county officials deserve praise for their efforts.
The clearance of the enormous camp along the Three Rivers Heritage Trail near the Allegheny County Jail (the “jail trail”), however, is not so cut and dried. Many of the people removed from that site have not been made “credible offers of housing,” and have simply relocated elsewhere in the city. This shoving-around of homeless people for the purposes of appearances is exactly what Mr. Gainey and his administration swore off, but have still engaged in time and again.
And once the DHS winter housing program ends, more people will once again experience unsheltered homelessness every night. Declaring victory now isn’t just inaccurate: It dangerously understates the work that still needs to be done.
A difficult task
The Gainey administration is in a difficult situation with regard to homelessness. First of all, homeless services are primarily a county responsibility, but because most visible homelessness is in the city — and often on city-controlled property — the mayor is considered by the public to be the most responsible party. This is often unfair. Mr. Gainey cannot pick up the slack if DHS struggles to fulfill its responsibilities, as it did last winter.
Further, the question of major homeless encampments raises thorny questions of competing values and interests, which this Editorial Board has also wrestled with. It is wrong and bad for unhoused people for the city to clear camps willy-nilly without making provision for them to have shelter. But it is also unhealthy and unsafe for the wider community — and, crucially, for unhoused people themselves — to explicitly or implicitly sanction encampments, especially when they encroach on public rights of way, such as popular trails.
This has been made more complicated by contradictory guidance given by the Gainey administration, which it also routinely fails to follow through on. For instance, in 2023 the administration released an official city policy to regulate encampments, including prohibiting tenting within 10 feet of a public right of way. But it has rarely been actually enforced, with the city implicitly permitting massive encampments in locations like the jail trail.
Then, the city’s Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank said the city wouldn’t clear encampments after all without being able to make “credible offers of housing” to those living in them. Yet this, too, has been regularly violated — including at the jail trail clearance Mr. Gainey is using to declare victory over homelessness.
Haphazard enforcement
While the portion of the Three Rivers Heritage Trail near the county jail has been restored to full, safe usage, that does not mean that all the city’s trails are free and clear — only the most visible one. On the South Side, for instance, community members and advocates observed an uptick in tenting along the South Side Riverfront Trail immediately after the jail trail clearance. (DHS denies that any jail trail residents have been observed along the South Side trail.)
In other words, while at least some people did receive shelter offers, others appear to have ended up moving to less visible areas of the city. That would be a political move, not an accomplishment, let alone a humane policy decision.
Then, the city briefly installed rocks on the flat landscape adjacent to the jail trail, to make a reemergence of the encampment impossible. But when homeless advocates objected, the city immediately removed them — and then Mr. Gainey’s office released a statement blaming a single, unnamed Public Works employee for installing the rocks without authorization. This beggars belief, and represents another clear example of the Gainey administration’s inability to take responsibility for its own actions.
Avoiding complacency
So, while one major trail has been restored, others have been predictably occupied. And while there are more spaces available for unhoused people to go inside, largely due to the efforts of county DHS, there’s still a significant unsheltered homelessness problem in Pittsburgh — it’s just been temporarily dispersed.
Plus, when the winter shelter at the Community Resource Mall in Perry Hilltop completes its seasonal service, there will be dozens fewer places for unhoused people to stay the night, and likely many more people, once again, living in tents.
It is undeniable that both the Gainey administration and Allegheny County DHS, under Director Erin Dalton and County Executive Sara Innamorato, have made progress in making shelter space and more permanent housing available for people who need it. Pittsburgh’s homelessness situation is better than it was 12 months ago.
However, it is extremely, and dangerously, premature for Mr. Gainey to declare victory. The city’s efforts, especially regarding encampments, continue to be haphazard, seemingly more responsive to news cycles and political exigencies than the realities on the ground. While Allegheny County appears to be making progress on Ms. Innamorato’s 500-in-500 housing pledge, the city still does not appear to have a coherent, long-term strategy to regulate encampments and to help move vulnerable people toward security and renewed independence.
Claiming the task is complete is a recipe for complacency — especially as winter soon comes to an end. That’s not what unhoused people need, and it’s not what Pittsburgh needs.
Clarification: This editorial has been edited to include context from the Allegheny County Department of Human Services regarding the displacement of unhoused people from the Three Rivers Heritage Trail near the Allegheny County Jail. While some South Side community members and advocates believe encampment residents moved to the South Side Riverfront Trail, DHS says it has seen no evidence of this migration.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.