When in the very near future — not if — Allegheny County undergoes a full reassessment of its roughly 600,000 parcels of real estate, the reassessment will result in tens of thousands of appeals. The county’s property-owners must have confidence that the appeals process is fair and efficient, rather than favoring the county’s need for funds over accuracy in its findings.

County-wide assessments are by nature, politically and practically, acrimonious, and that acrimony could negatively affect the county’s ability to perform its core duties.

That’s why it’s so important that County Council passes, and County Executive Sara Innamorato signs, a pair of bills sponsored by retiring Councilman Bob Macey, D-West Mifflin, that would ensure the independence of the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review (BPAAR).

This will correct an error made at the beginning of the county’s home-rule era, when the board that adjudicates appeals was made dependent on the county office responsible for the assessment itself.

Advertise with us

When Allegheny County adopted its Home Rule Charter at the turn of the millennium, it abolished a predecessor BPAAR that kept both the assessment and appeals functions independent (at least in theory) from the Board of Commissioners.

The current organization of BPAAR gives the office few duties, with its assessment function moved over to the Office of Property Assessment (OPA), which answers to the county manager, and ultimately, the county executive. The new organization of county government drastically reduced the duties of the new BPAAR to hearing and deciding appeals.

Separating the assessment and appeals functions wasn’t a bad idea. The problem is that, under current law, the appeals board depends on the OPA to fulfill its responsibilities. That gives the executive branch leverage it can use to influence the work of the nominally independent BPAAR.

For instance, OPA controls BPAARs purse strings. The assessment office controls the appeals board’s budget and staffing.

And then there’s a technical matter that is, in practice, at least as influential: Under the county’s administrative code, OPA must “process and schedule all appeals for the Appeals Board.” That means that the executive branch can construct the appeals schedule for its own benefit by, for instance, delaying hearings it knows will result in big revenue losses and refunds to taxpayers.

Advertise with us

The Macey bills would finally and fully establish BPAAR’s independence. This will give taxpayers confidence their appeals are being heard by a body equally accountable to all county stakeholders, not one that’s looking over its shoulder at the county executive’s office.

This isn’t to express suspicion of Sara Innamorato in particular, but rather to be realistic about the nature of power. The assessment function, and therefore the appeals function, is absolutely essential to county finances, and can be distorted in a nearly infinite variety of ways — and has been, from the days of powerful commissioners to the days of powerful county executives. Visible, functional independence is the only way to enhance public trust.

Some may argue that the county charter limits BPAAR’s functions merely to “hearing and deciding,” and not to staffing and scheduling, but this is far too narrow a reading. It stands to reason that the “hearing and deciding” duties come with all the other functions necessary to fulfill those duties effectively. There’s no good reason to deny those powers to the board. One would only deny them to maintain political leverage over the appeals process.

County Council will take up the Macey bills at Tuesday’s meeting, and we urge councilors to provide a veto-proof majority in order to strongly establish the principle of independence for property assessment appeals.