As climate change intensifies and natural disasters increase — like hurricanes not only in Florida but in Appalachia and multiple wild fires driven by days of high winds in Los Angeles — home insurers are increasingly abandoning coverage in places they risk losses far greater than the amount they can make in premiums.
Pittsburgh, a city not facing the same threat of wildfires or hurricanes or other natural disasters, should be well-protected from this kind of insurance company calculation. But it’s not, as the Post-Gazette’s Tim Grant reported on Feb. 3.
Increasingly stringent insurance requirements are due in part to Pittsburgh’s historic housing stock, some of the oldest in the nation — and specifically the ages of the roofs atop them. Many of these calculations affect first-time homebuyers buying homes with older roofs, as companies frequently require them to replace the roofs before approving the insurance necessary for the sale.
One reason for this trend is that as stronger storms batter homes, including damaging wind and hail storms, and the price of repairing roofs rises, insurers face large losses on what is becoming an increasingly common repair. The ease of fraudulently claiming storm damage to get a new roof is another reason for the rule. In some places, scammers pose as contractors in the wake of a severe weather event and convince homeowners to file inflated claims.
Insurance companies can’t be expected to insure homes when the premiums from their pool of customers may not cover the costs of repairing those homes. The industry that protects against risk isn’t going to take any financial risks.
There are ways to balance the insurance companies’ and homeowners’ needs. The state can place basic restrictions on the demands that insurers may make.
In Florida, for example, a recent law put guardrails in place so that insurance companies can’t refuse coverage solely because of a roof, if the roof is less than 15 years old. If it’s older than that and an inspector certifies that it will last five more years, the insurance company must insure it. In Texas, a law raising the deductible for hail-related damage has lowered the rate of fraudulent claims.
A visionary program in Alabama, meanwhile, is warding off the home insurance crisis before it begins. The state has helped thousands of homeowners pay for “fortified” roofs, which are specialized to withstand severe weather.
This fortified standard leads to less damage, lower premiums, and less risk for insurers. That’s not to mention the benefit to homeowners, who have better roofs and more assurance that their insurance company will pay for damage.
As Mr. Grant reported, the 15 year rule is keeping homebuyers in southwestern Pennsylvania from buying homes. With the weather getting worse, even here, the problem will also get worse. The legislature should follow Florida, Texas and Alabama in protecting homebuyers — and sellers.
Pennsylvania legislators have plenty of avenues to pursue in order to protect homeowners. Now is the time, before the full crisis reaches Pennsylvania, to begin the work.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.