Second in a series on troubling changes to Allegheny County’s residential mental health care system. You can find part one here.
While the Allegheny County Department of Human Services (DHS) defunds a key part of its system of residential care for people with serious mental illness (SMI), its own documents indicate that it’s sorting people with greater needs into the very facilities being gutted. This will leave the people being served with less care and they and their communities less secure.
These data-driven reforms at the famously data-driven department are meant to ensure that county residents with SMI are filtered into the appropriate kind and level of services. This sorts people with more complex mental and behavioral health struggles, including those with co-occurring substance use disorders, into community residential rehabilitation (CRR) facilities.
But these are the very group homes, sprinkled in neighborhoods around Pittsburgh, whose funding DHS is slicing in half — even as DHS itself will receive a historic windfall in 2025. This has forced the facilities to lay off caretakers and end 24-7 staffing.
DHS is currently executing this plan over the objections of the provider community. In fact, several leaders have alleged, including in an op-ed in the Post-Gazette, that DHS has instructed them not to discuss the matter even with their own staff. Which raises the question: If DHS is so confident in its new approach, why won’t it tolerate scrutiny?
Data-driven reform
Allegheny County DHS is known around the country as a pioneer in the use of data to predict residents’ needs and to prioritize the use of resources. The department’s Office of Analytics, Technology, and Planning is the most well-staffed office within the department, and was run by current DHS director Erin Dalton before she ascended to the directorship.
But the county’s data programs have not gone without controversy: Its Allegheny Family Screening Tool, which predicts which families will require more intensive interventions when referred for child welfare services, has reportedly come under Justice Department scrutiny for implicitly discriminating against poor families and racial minorities. Regardless, the department has continued to move full steam ahead by deploying more predictive assessments in more areas.
In 2020 came the Allegheny Housing Assessment (AHA), which is meant to help the department prioritize housing services. Then, early last year, DHS rolled out its mental health-focused version of the AHA, known as the MH-AHA.
The tool aims to quantify the probability of a client experiencing negative outcomes, including an inpatient stay or multiple visits to emergency rooms, in the near future. Clients are assigned a risk score between 1-10 based on their recent mental health and behavioral history, along with other risk factors.
The goal is to have an objective basis for prioritizing people with the most critical needs for supportive housing. Currently, wait times are long, and only half of clients receive a housing placement at all. Therefore DHS has instituted a cutoff: Only patients with an MH-AHA risk score of six or above will be eligible for the housing waitlist. The county says this will allow clients to receive a placement within 90 days, and will eventually eliminate the waitlist entirely.
This appears to be a good use of data to ensure the clients with the greatest needs get appropriate services first. In the November 2023 report laying out this plan, DHS plainly indicates that this will filter people with much higher MH-AHA scores into CRR facilities.
But then, the very next year, DHS set out to defund the CRR system.
Arbitrary reform
CRRs range from group homes to apartments where staff is on-site 24-7 to ensure peace among residents, help residents with everyday tasks, remind residents to take medication, prepare wholesome meals throughout the day, and provide a variety of other services. People who live in CRRs typically have overlapping mental and behavioral health issues, with co-occurring schizophrenia and substance use disorders being particularly common.
Those who have been prescribed this kind of housing typically cannot live safely with others or on their own without supervision — but the CRR program is meant to guide them toward independence. According to one report obtained by the Editorial Board, about one-third of CRR residents complete the prescribed program. The rest check themselves out against advice, or violate rules to the extent they are kicked out of the home.
These are some of the most challenging and delicate facilities to operate in all of human services. But they are also essential: Many residents would be homeless, and possibly dangerous to themselves or others, if they were not housed and served in a CRR.
This level of care is expensive, clocking in at about $50,000 per client per year for DHS. But this year, just as higher-needs clients were being filtered into CRRs, the department arbitrarily decreed this was too expensive. A recent DHS request for proposals for new residential mental health care providers has set the cost range between $21,000 and $31,000.
Providers have largely abandoned state licensing and the 24-7 model to fit these budget requirements. Others are closing entirely. In practice, the funding cut is ending the CRR model in Allegheny County. This is supposed to promote independence, according to DHS, even as the agency narrows its focus to clients who are least capable of independence.
Why? Ms. Dalton has said it was “inequitable” to spend $50,000 on CRR residents, but they are among the most complex clients in all of human services — of course caring for them is expensive. (And compare to the more than $60,000 Dauphin County spends on its CRR clients.) She has also suggested that CRRs are not “recovery-oriented” — but it is unclear how making them less supportive will make them more successful.
Meanwhile, those on the ground — CRR management, staff and clients — speak with one accord: Data is useful, but it isn’t everything. And trying to prove it is will be dangerous.
Next Sunday, the Editorial Board will explore the implications of the loss of CRRs for their clients and their communities.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.