As the City of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County continue to struggle with long-term increases in homelessness, a protest against encampment clearances staged at Mayor Ed Gainey’s private residence in Lincoln-Lemington on Monday demonstrated exactly how not to address the issue compassionately and productively.
While the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has been consistently critical of Mr. Gainey’s leadership, ever since cracks in city government became visible about a year into his term, there is never justification for violating the privacy and security of elected officials, their families and their neighbors. While the protesters have an undeniable First-Amendment right to speak, even loudly and obnoxiously, on public property adjacent to the Mayor’s home, the Gainey family and their community also have a moral right to live in peace.
This particular protest, however, included more than just protected speech: It veered into trespassing. Photographs of the event taken for the Post-Gazette show a tent pitched by the protestors in Mr. Gainey’s own driveway — that is, on his property. This goes beyond the indecency of harassing the Mayor’s family and disrupting his neighborhood, into clearly illegal territory. While Mr. Gainey has practical incentives not to press charges, which could further inflame the activists and damage his political standing on the left, he would be justified in doing so.
These tactics do nothing to mitigate the real problems that continue to face Pittsburgh and the city’s most vulnerable residents. That will require a level of coordination and candor that has been consistently lacking from City Hall.
City-county coordination
While the protestors’ tactics were unsound, their passion is rooted in realty: The city’s policies regarding homeless encampments have been enforced arbitrarily, and the modest expansion of winter shelter beds does not constitute a sustainable solution to the housing and services people living on the streets need.
Pittsburgh’s response to homelessness depends on coordination between the City of Pittsburgh and the Allegheny County Department of Human Services. DHS has primary responsibility for marshaling public resources, especially state funds, to organize a comprehensive system of shelters and more permanent housing that’s designed to move vulnerable people incrementally toward renewed independence.
While DHS has more successfully prepared for frigid winter weather this year than last, it continues to struggle to design and implement a plan that’s more than bandages applied to gaping wounds.
The city, meanwhile, has public health and safety responsibilities of its own, including regarding the use of public spaces within its jurisdiction. But ultimately the city’s homelessness policies — including its encampment clearance policy — are only complementary with, and therefore dependent on, the county’s.
Credible offers
The encampment policy, published last summer, sets out a list of criteria that would trigger a sweep, including proximity to a public right-of-way or evidence of illegal activity. Every encampment fulfills these criteria, so the city’s Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank retroactively added another criterion: The city (and therefore, in practice, the county) must be able to make a “credible offer of housing” to those being displaced from encampments.
The definition of this “credible offer,” however, has been tortured from the beginning. This spring, for instance, the Gainey administration claimed it made “credible offers” to those displaced from cleared Downtown camps, but county data showed that there were almost no available shelter beds. Mr. Gainey has since gone on to brag about clearing the Downtown camps, despite the fact that doing so violated the “credible offer” policy.
At the same time, the city cannot afford to allow encampments to fester indefinitely. Besides the quality of life issues presented to housed residents, most notably along the region’s popular riverfront trails, these makeshift neighborhoods are simply awful places to live. Physical and sexual assaults are commonplace, and drug dealers take advantage of the residents not just by distributing narcotics, but by stashing their supplies in tents, where unhoused people will take the fall for possessing them.
Ms. Frank has pledged that this winter’s sweeps represent “a new era” for the policy, which she calls “planful” and “inviting people inside.” But this seriously overstates the progress the city and the county have made. For instance, many people displaced from encampments this month have been sent to the former McNaugher School in Perry Hilltop, which DHS has designated as an overflow winter shelter. But it’s meant to be temporary, and being run by organizations with no previous experience running such a facility.
Is it an improvement over last year’s cobbled-together Code Blue winter plan? Probably. Is it a sustainable solution to homelessness in Pittsburgh. Certainly not.
Mounting indignities
At Mr. Gainey’s home on Monday evening, the protestors held a sign that read “We want long-term housing solutions or freedom to camp.” The former is what everyone wants. The latter is an impossibility: It’s bad for public health and safety in Pittsburgh, and bad for the people living in the encampments. There cannot be a freedom to occupy public spaces indefinitely.
Getting to those “long-term housing solutions” is the difficulty. While the Gainey administration cannot be faulted for the slow pace of progress at the county level, it can be faulted for making promises it can’t or won’t keep. First, the city promised to clear dangerous encampments, and then it didn’t. Later, the city promised not to clear camps without credible offers of housing, and then it did.
But screaming at the Mayor’s private home through a bullhorn does nothing to resolve this immensely challenging policy and humanitarian quandary. Its only effect is to continue to dissuade decent people — like Ed Gainey — from seeking public office, if they expect their homes and families will be targeted with insults and simplistic slogans regarding complex issues.
The indignity of homelessness in Pittsburgh will not be solved by further indignities. It will be solved by collaborative leadership.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.