Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato’s first budget has become the county’s highest-stakes policy and political battle in recent memory. The results will set a course for taxation, and for county government operations and finances, for years or even decades to come.

Through the process, Ms. Innamorato has stuck to her guns, barnstorming around the county to demonstrate how revenues from her proposed 2.2-mil property tax hike would expand — and, arguably, simply preserve — county services in everything from public safety to care for the elderly and disabled.

However, because the county’s home rule charter requires a County Council supermajority to raise taxes, Ms. Innamorato needs 10 of 15 votes in the legislature to pass her budget. She does not have them, and cannot get them. Further, it is clear that the relationship between the young administration and council is strained, marked by miscommunication and mutual distrust.

On Tuesday evening, the council’s Budget and Finance Committee passed a pared-back budget of its own with a tax increase of 1.35 mils, which will appear before the full body on Dec. 3. Both sides are adamant that the other has not been willing to negotiate a compromise in good faith.

Advertise with us

As a result, Allegheny County is staring down a charter-imposed deadline of Dec. 6 to approve a budget. If that deadline is missed, Ms. Innamorato and council would have until the end of the month to avoid a shutdown of government services, including missing payroll.

That cannot happen. And so we renew our call for a compromise tax hike of around 1.8 mils, softened by a generous expansion of the homestead exemption for owner-occupied residences.

Delayed reckoning

A substantial tax increase is necessary because sluggish economic growth and an aging population mean that county government expenses grow faster than revenues. Tax rates remained flat under former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald because an inflated common level ratio kept assessed property values, and therefore revenues, artificially high. Then federal COVID relief funds put off the reckoning for four years.

But those funds are expiring and the courts have restored a fair CLR. Over a decade of accumulating pressure must finally be released.

Ms. Innamorato’s 2.2-mil proposal represents a 46.5% increase over current county real estate levies, but that figure overstates the effect on everyday residents. Because the county represents the smallest share of property taxes, the actual tax increase will range from about 4% in areas with already-high property taxes to nearly 10% in the City of Pittsburgh, where property taxes are deflated due to a high 3% earned income tax.

Advertise with us

For the median homeowner in the county, with property valued at a little over $110,000, the 2.2-mil hike would mean about $200 more per year (after the homestead exemption is applied). That will be much higher for people with more expensive homes, but that’s simply the nature of taxation.

An aggressive tax hike will exacerbate existing inequities in the county’s real estate assessment system, but this is unavoidable: The county needs the money now, and a countywide reassessment was never going to commence before 2025. We continue to urge Ms. Innamorato to begin the reassessment as soon as possible, while reforming the county’s assessment practices so these crises do not recur in the future.

Bad faith

Despite the recriminations between the branches, neither Ms. Innamorato’s 2.2-mil opening bid nor council’s 1.35-mil reply are unreasonable. The former would comfortably fund the government and replenish the diminished reserves in a single year; the latter would preserve services and avoid layoffs — it includes 3% payroll budget increases across the board — while spreading out reserve-replenishment over several years.

The administration has overstated the threat to county jobs and services from proposals under 2.2 mils, while council has underestimated the threat to long-term financial sustainability from its much smaller proposal. Especially with the unpredictability of a countywide reassessment on the horizon, erring on the side of raising more revenues now, rather than being forced to supplement this year’s hike in the years to come, is prudent.

Unfortunately, the relationship between the Innamorato administration and County Council has apparently not allowed for this kind of give and take. While several meetings between the county executive’s senior staff and members of council have occurred, both sides appear to feel that the other has offered only threats and ultimatums, and neither side appears to believe the other is interested in fair negotiations.

Advertise with us

Real compromise

This is particularly frustrating because there are intelligent, workable compromises immediately at hand. For instance, splitting the difference with the council proposal — say, 1.8 mils — would avoid layoffs, maintain services and quickly refill the county’s reserve funds. The reserves are especially important given political and economic uncertainty, as well as to be prepared for a variety of union contracts expiring during the 2025 fiscal year.

Further, a more generous increase in the homestead exemption, which sets aside a portion of the value of an owner-occupied property tax-free, would shield homeowners from some of the effects of the hike, and shift the overall tax burden onto commercial real estate. This is particularly warranted because collapsing commercial property values have already shifted the burden the other way, onto residential.

The Innamorato plan would increase the exemption from $18,000 to $21,000. A figure closer to $30,000 would be even better. Council’s elimination of the Innamorato expansion, however, is the weakest part of its counter-offer: It would only further burden county homeowners and protect commercial property interests.

This budget season is a trial-by-fire for the young Innamorato administration — the kind of political and governing challenge even a seasoned executive would struggle to negotiate. We hope and expect that her personal outreach to council, expected this week, will break the logjam and achieve a smart compromise that maintains county services and promotes fiscal responsibility, without charging taxpayers any more than is necessary.