There’s no better time than the day after America’s great candy holiday to consider the economics of dental care.
Back in 2011, the Pennsylvania General Assembly passed a bill cutting Medicaid benefits for dental care. While Pennsylvania is still middle-of-the pack for what procedures its low-income insurance will cover, trimming tooth-care is a decidedly poor bet, both financially and for Pennsylvanians’ health.
The change was estimated to save the commonwealth $18.9 million per year. What happened instead, as the Pennsylvania Coalition for Oral Health estimates based on a 2023 study, is that emergency room dental care costs across the state rose by $35 million annually.
Recent studies have shown that nearly 80% of oral care emergency room visits would be better handled by a dentist. And states that have implemented dental Medicaid expansions have shown a 14% reduction in these emergency visits only one year after expanding their benefits.
While Medicaid in Pennsylvania still covers routine dental procedures like cleanings, fillings and extractions, anything beyond this scope, like a root canal, will only be approved through what is known as a “benefit limit exception.” Approvals of BLEs are so rare that dentists report rejection rates of well over 90%.
The full cost to the state of returning the Medicaid program to its 2011 status would now be about $40 million, which means the net cost — when that $35 million in emergency room visits is taken into account — is only $5 million. For that $5 million, the state would relieve one form of unnecessary stress on emergency departments, while ensuring more people receive the kind of preventative care that saves money and preserves health down the road.
Teeth are also a uniquely bad bet for skimping on medical care. Oral pain and discomfort rarely points to an issue that will heal on their own. Putting off dental care always results in more extensive, complex and painful procedures down the road. Dental work also costs three to five times more at an emergency room, and, in the worst cases, patients are sent home with nothing more than pain management or antibiotics because that’s all the hospital can offer.
Then there is the social stigma associated with poor oral health. In states without any Medicaid dental benefits, 60% of Medicaid users report that the appearance of their teeth has impacted their employability. In states where this benefit is accessible, that number drops to 35%. So there is an unmeasurable economic benefit to funding dental care that reaches beyond the direct medical costs.
But simply adding to what Medicaid covers won’t resolve other problems with the program. As with many other medical treatments under Medicaid, federal reimbursements are too low for dentists to recoup the cost of providing care to low-income patients. As a result, the majority of dentists don’t take on Medicaid patients, making the search for dental care another arduous process during which patients’ health can deteriorate. Any broader reform of Medicaid must take into account the importance of dental care.
While Pennsylvania must remain vigilant about its spending, dental health for the state’s poorest residents shouldn’t be at the forefront of cost-saving measures. Bipartisan efforts to reinstate Medicaid’s dental coverage to pre-2011 levels stalled in the state senate early this year. The effort should be revived and passed into law.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.