Alle­gheny County’s Depart­ment of Human Ser­vices (DHS) is pro­ject­ing con­fi­dence in its shel­ter sys­tem en­ter­ing win­ter, go­ing so far as to elim­i­nate last year’s Code Blue emer­gency pro­to­col in fa­vor of ex­pand­ing 24/​7 shel­ter fa­cil­i­ties. It’s the kind of plan­ning the de­part­ment failed to com­plete be­fore the cold set in last win­ter, with tragic re­sults.

But af­ter years of the home­less­ness cri­sis out­pac­ing good-faith ef­forts to ade­quately care for peo­ple, un­housed peo­ple and those who serve them are right to re­main skep­ti­cal. Will the ex­panded shel­ter ca­pac­ity — in­clud­ing a newly re­opened Second Avenue Com­mons — suf­fice, when the num­ber of peo­ple ex­pe­ri­enc­ing home­less­ness rises through­out the sea­son? DHS be­lieves it will, but only time will tell.

The de­part­ment’s plan in­cludes ex­pand­ing shel­ter ca­pac­ity by over 100 beds be­gin­ning on Nov. 15 — and, cru­cially, keep­ing these fa­cil­i­ties open dur­ing day­light and night­time hours while pro­vid­ing med­i­cal and so­cial ser­vices. This stands in con­trast to pre­vi­ous years, when many shel­ters opened only for over­night guests, ex­cept for Code Blue pro­to­cols.

Last year, DHS in­sti­tuted Code Blue af­ter a bru­tal No­vem­ber cold snap caught the de­part­ment un­pre­pared and re­sulted in doz­ens of un­housed peo­ple re­ceiv­ing noth­ing more than “sur­vival sup­plies” — and hopes and prayers they’d live to see the morn­ing. Code Blue was trig­gered when win­ter tem­per­a­tures dipped be­low 26 de­grees, ex­pand­ing shel­ter hours and pro­vid­ing buss­ing to a tem­po­rary warm­ing cen­ter at the Am­mon Recre­ation Center in the Hill Dis­trict.

Advertise with us

But Code Blue was al­ways a band-aid mea­sure. Its tem­per­a­ture thresh­old was ar­bi­trary, and didn’t take into ac­count other dan­ger­ous con­di­tions, like cold rain or flood­ing — in­clud­ing high wa­ter last Jan­u­ary that swept doz­ens of tents into the three riv­ers. Un­housed peo­ple faced se­vere health con­se­quences last year, in­clud­ing sev­eral in­stances of frost­bite.

Ex­panded 24/​7 shel­ter ca­pac­ity is a clear up­grade. DHS states that over 600 beds will be avail­able dur­ing the win­ter sea­son, start­ing in mid-No­vem­ber and run­ning through mid-March. Fur­ther, an­other new win­ter shel­ter will open on the North Side in early Decem­ber, which is said to “have suf­fi­cient ca­pac­ity to shel­ter any­one who needs a safe place to stay.”

This is im­por­tant, be­cause there’s good rea­son to be­lieve that 600 will not be enough shel­ter beds. DHS data from this week show nearly 400 peo­ple us­ing adult-only shel­ters, while up to 200 live un­shel­tered on the streets. That al­ready nears 600, and win­ter hasn’t even started yet.

Fur­ther, this past Jan­u­ary’s an­nual “point-in-time count” found 533 peo­ple liv­ing in adult shel­ters and, again, nearly 200 on the streets. That’s well more than 600. If home­less­ness in­creases this win­ter and ap­proaches last year’s num­bers, as it well might, even the new, more ro­bust sys­tem will be in­suf­fi­cient with­out an over­flow shel­ter.

Cal­cu­lat­ing the true num­ber of home­less peo­ple in Al­le­gheny County has al­ways been tricky. People with­out sta­ble hous­ing travel of­ten, uti­lize a va­ri­ety of county ser­vices, and don’t al­ways fall into a clear cut cat­e­gory of need. Over and over again, emerg­ing county ser­vices like new shel­ters or sin­gle-room oc­cu­pancy houses be­come in­ad­e­quate in the face of ris­ing de­mand.

Advertise with us

The prime ex­am­ple is Second Avenue Com­mons, the linch­pin of the re­gion’s home­less­ness ef­forts. The fa­cil­ity was the cul­mi­na­tion of years of pub­lic and pri­vate sec­tor co­or­di­na­tion, but was al­ready too small upon com­ple­tion. The fa­cil­ity had been at ca­pac­ity since open­ing its doors in 2022, un­til a fire ear­lier this year closed it for sev­eral months.

Al­le­gheny County’s new win­ter shel­ter plan, un­like last year’s, has all the in­di­ca­tors of a con­sid­ered and com­pe­tent ap­proach to the on­go­ing cri­sis of home­less­ness in Pitts­burgh. Whether it suc­ceeds will come down to how well that plan is ex­e­cuted — and how many homeless people the city has.