Allegheny County’s Department of Human Services (DHS) is projecting confidence in its shelter system entering winter, going so far as to eliminate last year’s Code Blue emergency protocol in favor of expanding 24/7 shelter facilities. It’s the kind of planning the department failed to complete before the cold set in last winter, with tragic results.
But after years of the homelessness crisis outpacing good-faith efforts to adequately care for people, unhoused people and those who serve them are right to remain skeptical. Will the expanded shelter capacity — including a newly reopened Second Avenue Commons — suffice, when the number of people experiencing homelessness rises throughout the season? DHS believes it will, but only time will tell.
The department’s plan includes expanding shelter capacity by over 100 beds beginning on Nov. 15 — and, crucially, keeping these facilities open during daylight and nighttime hours while providing medical and social services. This stands in contrast to previous years, when many shelters opened only for overnight guests, except for Code Blue protocols.
Last year, DHS instituted Code Blue after a brutal November cold snap caught the department unprepared and resulted in dozens of unhoused people receiving nothing more than “survival supplies” — and hopes and prayers they’d live to see the morning. Code Blue was triggered when winter temperatures dipped below 26 degrees, expanding shelter hours and providing bussing to a temporary warming center at the Ammon Recreation Center in the Hill District.
But Code Blue was always a band-aid measure. Its temperature threshold was arbitrary, and didn’t take into account other dangerous conditions, like cold rain or flooding — including high water last January that swept dozens of tents into the three rivers. Unhoused people faced severe health consequences last year, including several instances of frostbite.
Expanded 24/7 shelter capacity is a clear upgrade. DHS states that over 600 beds will be available during the winter season, starting in mid-November and running through mid-March. Further, another new winter shelter will open on the North Side in early December, which is said to “have sufficient capacity to shelter anyone who needs a safe place to stay.”
This is important, because there’s good reason to believe that 600 will not be enough shelter beds. DHS data from this week show nearly 400 people using adult-only shelters, while up to 200 live unsheltered on the streets. That already nears 600, and winter hasn’t even started yet.
Further, this past January’s annual “point-in-time count” found 533 people living in adult shelters and, again, nearly 200 on the streets. That’s well more than 600. If homelessness increases this winter and approaches last year’s numbers, as it well might, even the new, more robust system will be insufficient without an overflow shelter.
Calculating the true number of homeless people in Allegheny County has always been tricky. People without stable housing travel often, utilize a variety of county services, and don’t always fall into a clear cut category of need. Over and over again, emerging county services like new shelters or single-room occupancy houses become inadequate in the face of rising demand.
The prime example is Second Avenue Commons, the linchpin of the region’s homelessness efforts. The facility was the culmination of years of public and private sector coordination, but was already too small upon completion. The facility had been at capacity since opening its doors in 2022, until a fire earlier this year closed it for several months.
Allegheny County’s new winter shelter plan, unlike last year’s, has all the indicators of a considered and competent approach to the ongoing crisis of homelessness in Pittsburgh. Whether it succeeds will come down to how well that plan is executed — and how many homeless people the city has.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.