Seemingly well-intentioned proposals to make it easier to set aside housing for Pittsburgh’s most vulnerable residents — known collectively as the “Fair Housing Amendments” to the city’s zoning code — are likely to backfire. Despite advocates’ intentions, their effect will likely be to open up a wild west of speculation and slumlordism that hurts the very people they’re meant to help, while causing declines in safety and livability for everyone else. These proposals must be refined before they are passed.
A letter sent by city Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith to her largely West End constituents, which accurately stated that the amendments would allow uses such as small homeless shelters in every residential district of the city without public notice or process, set off a firestorm that culminated at the city’s Planning Commission last Tuesday. More residents showed up than could fit in the hearing room, and the commission postponed consideration until its next meeting in four weeks.
These events, and the framing around homeless shelters, have come to define the contours of the debate, with some alleging that opposing the amendments is tantamount to refusing housing to people experiencing unsheltered homelessness. But this is both simplistic and myopic: The implications of the Fair Housing Amendments actually go much farther than addressing homelessness. Indeed, they could transform Pittsburgh in way their supporters don’t appear to understand.
Paved with good intentions
The Fair Housing Amendments constitute nearly 80 pages of changes to Pittsburgh’s zoning code, which are said to bring that code into alignment with the federal Fair Housing Act. This is dubious, because many of the provisions in the amendments are not at all common in cities around the country. If anything, the proposals would take Pittsburgh’s land use policies seriously out of step with peer cities’.
The fundamental purpose behind the amendments is to remove discrimination on the basis of any protected class — including disability, very broadly defined — from Pittsburgh’s zoning code. The amendments achieve this through a variety of complicated maneuvers, but they can be distilled to this: The proposal aims to treat property uses that serve vulnerable people, such as homeless shelters and substance abuse recovery homes, on par with those used by everyone else.
In practice, that means that anywhere a family of four is allowed to live without seeking or receiving permission from the city, a group of four (or, as we will see, six or eight or more) unrelated people recovering from homelessness or substance abuse must also be allowed to live without seeking or receiving permission. In other words, any home in the city can become a small shelter or recovery home (or other similar uses) without any public process or subsequent oversight.
One of the key changes that achieves this goal is redefining “family,” for the purposes of zoning, to mean a group of persons of any number, related or unrelated, who share housekeeping. The implications of this change are enormous, and potentially transformative.
Slumlord millionaires
While the intention behind making this change is to maximize the availability of housing for vulnerable Pittsburghers, its effect — when combined with the sharp rise in the corporate ownership of housing in Pittsburgh and elsewhere — will be to maximize opportunities for exploitation. The Fair Housing Amendments, as written, amount to a blaring signal to every unscrupulous property company in (and beyond) America: “Come to Pittsburgh, where you can do whatever you like!”
Imagine a three-bedroom single-family home in Brighton Heights on the market for $250,000. A New York-based LLC, likely a shell company affiliated with a much larger corporation, swoops in with a cash offer of $275,000, which is hard for the owner to reject and serves to drive up prices for everyone else. Under current regulations, the corporation can rent this home to either a family of any number of persons “related by blood or marriage or adoption,” or up to three unrelated people who share the premises.
But under the Fair Housing Amendments, the corporation would be allowed to squeeze as many people as it likes into that Brighton Heights home. Given the choice between renting at $1,500 to a family or at $500 to each of eight people, for a total of $4,000, it’s clear where a profit-maximizing corporation will go.
Further, many of these corporation-owned homes could and would be marketed as “transitional” or “recovery” homes for people currently in shelters and/or struggling with substance use disorder — with no actual services offered to help the residents, or oversight to protect the surrounding neighborhood. This would only further entrench the revolving door of homelessness and substance abuse: While it might temporarily get some people off the streets, it will not help them progress toward renewed independence.
Pittsburgh is not for sale
There is one place in Pittsburgh where the three-unrelated-person housing cap is regularly violated: Oakland, where several students regularly share residences meant for one family. Because the city also lacks a rental registry and inspection authority, this situation goes largely unchecked, and so Oakland rental homes are often teeming, notoriously dingy and frequently unsafe.
Student housing in Oakland is an argument for raising the cap of three unrelated persons in a residence — perhaps to four or five — in order to incentivize owners to work within the bounds of city regulations, rather than outside them. It is not an argument in favor of removing the cap entirely, which would risk spreading the Oakland situation citywide.
Despite the intention to help vulnerable Pittsburghers, in practice the Fair Housing Amendments represent an invitation to exploit them. At the same time, the new rules would offer up city homes and neighborhoods to the highest bidder: nameless, faceless, out-of-town corporate slumlords. Pittsburgh’s land-use policies need reform, but it can’t become the Wild West — without even a sheriff to fight off the bandits.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.