The yearlong lawsuit between Allegheny County Council and the Office of the County Executive concerning the Highland Detention at Shuman Center has finally been put to rest. Now that County Council has abandoned their turf war with the county executive, the focus can return to what actually matters: keeping children out of adult criminal facilities.

Council’s lawsuit argued that the county executive’s office, then under Rich Fitzgerald, had overstepped its power by contracting with Adelphoi, the new private operator at Shuman, without a county council vote. The matter is further complicated by the fact that the county’s courts system — under the leadership last year of President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark, now of President Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente — is also involved, by statute, in overseeing the juvenile detention system

Last Tuesday, the council voted 13-1-1 to settle the lawsuit. The framework is this: County council may weigh in on the appointment of one Shuman Advisory Board member; the board will receive detailed weekly operations updates from Adelphoi; and County Council will be able to vote on the renewal of the contract five years from now.

Firebrand Councilwoman Bethany Hallam voted against the deal due to her ongoing concerns about contracting with a private entity and the details of council’s oversight, while Councilman DeWitt Walton abstained as a protest against the very existence of the lawsuit, which he opposed. County Council members seemed (nearly) uniformly exhausted with the endeavor.

Advertise with us

County Executive Sara Innamorato inherited the lawsuit, which council had filed last year challenging Mr. Fitzgerald’s authority under the county’s Home Rule Charter to contract with a private organization to run the detention center without council’s approval. The case turned on whether he county executive was contracting for a service or conveying property, which would require council’s consent. It was one of multiple attempts in recent years by council to carve out more authority for itself within the only two-decade-old charter.

But this was not the time for legal grandstanding. While the branches tussled, young people were not being served well by the county’s juvenile justice system. Adelphoi estimates that, from December 2021 to October 2023, 234 young offenders would have been eligible for Shuman’s facilities.

Instead, minors with criminal charges have had nothing but bad options: being held, either in isolation or with adults, at the chronically-understaffed Allegheny County Jail; being sent to youth facilities outside of the county and away from friend and family networks; or being released on electronic monitoring, which has resulted in hundreds of damaged monitoring devices and at least one murder. Juvenile detention is not right for every offender, but it is right for some, and is an essential component of any effective system.

The settlement is generally a political and policy victory for Ms. Innamorato. It clears this distraction while progressing toward the full re-opening of Shuman, while also isolating Ms. Hallam — suggesting a possibly durable alliance against challenges from the county executive’s left flank.

The settlement, however, does not resolve the larger question of the county executive’s contracting power. Ms. Innamorato’s concession that council can decide the renewal of the Adelphoi contract five years hence should be be taken by future courts as a concession on the interpretation of the charter. The branches should find another way to resolve this issue permanently, one that doesn’t place vulnerable young people in the crossfire.