Public documents reviewed by the Post-Gazette Editorial board indicate that the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh removed a qualified minority-owned business from a contract — even after the authority’s plan had been approved by the city's Equal Opportunity Review Commission (EORC). Even worse: The resulting work was shoddy and violated the terms of the work contract, so the agency booted a minority-owned business only to get bad results.
This marks the second unusual HACP contract reviewed by the Editorial Board in recent months: In July the Board described a contract for security services which was split in two, with a less qualified firm — which is owned by Republican state Senate candidate Jen Dintini and whose workers are represented by the politically powerful SEIU 32BJ union — inexplicably receiving the more lucrative part of the work.
In this case, the discrepancy between the plan approved by the EORC and the contract executed by the HACP demonstrates either brazen deception or remarkable incompetence within the housing authority, as well as the diversity commission’s inability to enforce its own decisions.
These revelations raise further questions about procurement practices at HACP, which merit further investigation — likely at the federal level, since the authority is funded by the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). But they also suggest that the Gainey administration is too disorganized and feckless to fulfill its obligations under the law, even in areas of the highest priority, like equity and diversity in contracting.
Changing plans
In March 2023, HACP received four bids for “site erosion abatement” — work to mitigate areas of bare dirt at its public housing properties, to ensure compliance with HUD safety and environmental standards. Two bids were disqualified, one for lack of qualifications and another for price. That left Tri Rivers Property Maintenance, a certified minority business enterprise (MBE), and Mountain Valley Services, which came in at a slightly lower price.
To fulfill its own and the city’s standards for diversity in contracting, on April 20 HACP proposed a plan to the EORC whereby it would split the $4.5 million contract equally between Tri Rivers and Mountain Valley. The EORC reviews and approves contracts with the city and city agencies, like HACP, to ensure they comply with local laws while advancing equity and diversity goals. A quorum of six of the commission’s 11 members approved HACP’s 50/50 split for the erosion abatement work.
But then, only one week later, the HACP board unanimously approved a $4.5 million contract — with Mountain Valley Services, the non-MBE candidate, alone. Remarkably, among the votes for the contract, which diverged from the EORC-approved plan and eliminated a certified MBE contractor, was the HACP board president and chief of staff to Mayor Ed Gainey, Jake Wheatley.
This series of events suggests either that HACP personnel intentionally misled the diversity commission, or (less likely) that somehow the procurement office inadvertently proposed different contracts to the EORC and to its own board. But it also shows that the EORC is completely incapable of enforcing its own decisions.
Out of commission
Pittsburgh’s business diversity commission appears to have gotten lost in the restructuring of city government under the Peduto and Gainey administrations. In city code, the EORC is meant to be overseen by the “Department of Neighborhood Empowerment and Equal Opportunity.” But that department no longer exists.
In 2019, Bill Peduto rechristened the department the Office of Equity. Then, as part of his mania for dismantling all reminders of the Peduto years, Mr. Gainey folded that office into the burgeoning Mayor’s Office and split it up into several much smaller divisions. The office that oversees the EORC seems to be the Office of Business Diversity, though it’s hard to say which office within the Mayor’s Office is, legally, the successor to the Neighborhood Empowerment department. There may not be one at all.
Under city code, the EORC’s supervisory department is supposed to maintain a database tracking MBE/WBE contracting, and to follow up quarterly with diverse vendors who receive contracts from the city and its agencies to ensure all parties are complying with the terms of those contracts. There is no evidence the Mayor’s Office, or any of its sub-offices, is doing either of these things.
This would be a good place for the city’s tenacious Controller Rachael Heisler to probe: The EORC hasn’t received a performance audit from the Controller’s Office in a dozen years.
Paying the price
HACP’s contracting issues, and the EORC’s impotence, are more than bureaucratic failures: They also lower the standard of living for the housing authority’s residents. In the case of the erosion abatement bid, the rejected contractor was a long-time local vendor for HACP, and the chosen one parachuted in from Elk County — and performed shoddy work.
Photos reviewed by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board show “erosion abatement” work at HACP’s Northview Heights community that consists of little more than straw dropped on top of patches of dirt. Besides being unsightly and ineffective, the work contract specifically forbids straw as a “non-compliant material.” For this, across the authority’s properties, Mountain Valley Services received $4.5 million.
This single contract serves as a remarkable window into the dishonesty, the incompetence and the heedlessness of public leadership in Pittsburgh, from the Mayor’s Office to the housing authority. And it demands further investigation, and reforms — because it’s the city’s taxpayers, and its most vulnerable residents, who are paying the price.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.