Pittsburgh has been trying to create a registry of rental properties for the last 16 years. It’s time to hold the trade groups and businesses that are standing in the way accountable: They’re harming renters and hampering the ability of the city to rein in harmful out-of-state LLCs.
The arguments against the registry have fallen flat for years, and the city has shown ample ability to tweak and update policies based on genuine legal issues. When landlord organizations argued that per unit registration fees were too high, the city lowered them. When they opposed a landlord training requirement, the city removed it. When they balked at the possibility of a public list of rental contacts, the city allowed it to remain private.
But these groups have continued suing, no matter what concessions the city makes.
The stakes are high. As Post-Gazette reporting has uncovered, out-of-state LLCs can buy properties while obscuring ownership to avoid accountability. Some even sell these properties back to their own subsidiaries in order to escape code violations.
This is especially dangerous for renters, who may become trapped in a decaying property whose ownership is unclear. A rental registry would allow the city to properly monitor the rental market and pinpoint areas of abuse and deception, and renters to know who, exactly, they’re renting from.
It works: Cities with rental registries consistently report a drop in the number of dilapidated rental units and absentee landlords.
Among the two biggest players opposing the rental registry are the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh (AAMP) and the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh (RAMP). Both have argued that various iterations of the rental registry constitute an overreach of city government, require too much of landlords, or simply cost too much.
But it’s clear the details don’t really matter. Landlord groups have taken the city to court over every iteration of the rental registry, starting with the 2008 version and its $12 fee, the 2014 one that would have charged between $45 and $65 per unit, and the 2021 iteration, which would charge $14 per unit, every few years.
Lawrence Fisher, who currently represents the AAMP in its legal challenge against the rental registry, called the registry a “money grab.” But the AAMP itself charges annual membership fees that cash out to up to $10 per year per unit — or more for smaller landlords.
Meanwhile, other Pennsylvania cities like Erie, Allentown and Harrisburg have rental registries that charge more than Pittsburgh’s would. In Allentown, a court held that a $75 fee per residential unit was justified for the expense of inspections. Even smaller communities like Sharpsburg, Millvale and McKees Rocks have been able to launch rental registries without legal obstructions, or damaging the rental market.
Pittsburgh should have been able to enact this common-sense legislation years ago. The city’s good-faith efforts deserve a good-faith response from landlord associations: Accept the rental registry.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.