Thursday’s city-ordered work stoppage at the largest construction site in the City of Pittsburgh — indeed, one of the few construction sites of any note in the city — is a striking example of the Gainey administration’s inability, or unwillingness, to work constructively with partners outside a small circle of political trust. As this episode demonstrates, that circle does not include disfavored labor unions.

The stop order — called “red-tagging” — at the $1.5 billion UPMC Presbyterian hospital construction site in Oakland has not been lifted as of this writing on Friday afternoon. This is despite assurances given on Thursday by Mayor Ed Gainey to Greg Bernarding, executive business manager for the Pittsburgh Regional Building and Construction Trades Council, that permitting would be expedited. That means up to 150 union workers have been idled. And when they aren’t allowed to work, they don’t get paid.

Meanwhile, there’s not many other sites to work on in a city that has turned decidedly against development.

This situation is on the one hand unprecedented, and on the other hand par for the course. Completely stopping work, and threatening the livelihoods of dozens of union families, over permitting technicalities is simply not done. Multiple sources with decades of experience with construction in Pittsburgh cannot remember any time when the city red-tagged a site like this with no warning, and no attempt to reach an amicable resolution that maintained safety and compliance while keeping workers on the job.

Advertise with us

Yet this heavy- and high-handed approach has become a hallmark of the Gainey administration. It’s why economic development in Pittsburgh, and not just Downtown, has slowed to a trickle. It’s why there’s nowhere else for idled building trades workers to use their skills, and to get paid.

Business as usual

There was nothing unusual about Thursday, June 20, at the UPMC site. While various subcontractors had been in communication with the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections (PLI) for months about sewing up details for various construction permits, no particular permits expired on that day or the day before. There were no Wednesday or Thursday deadlines that were missed. Everyone expected to work as usual.

That’s because the process of building and permitting in Pittsburgh is best described as “dynamic.” Especially on complicated projects like a billion-dollar hospital, there are dozens of permits being handled by PLI and a variety of contractors. Sometimes the department and contractors spend weeks or months trading requests and responses to requests for information or clarification.

For instance, at the UPMC site, at least some of the permits in question had been filed in December, and had been in limbo since. While these details are ironed out, typically work continues under the supervision of a PLI inspector — and that was the case here, as it is at the few other major work sites around Pittsburgh.

Any implication from city officials that UPMC’s contractors were operating in a lawless or negligent way is untrue. The same city inspector was there every day, and he had raised no alarms about compliance or safety.

Advertise with us

Until Thursday, when a different inspector showed up at the work site.

Needless distress

Without warning, that inspector declared part of the site to be in violation of city code, and shut it down. About 150 union workers were sent home. Again, they will not be paid for hours and days they don’t work.

The statement given to Post-Gazette news partner KDKA by Mr. Gainey’s communications director, Maria Montaño, that the city had “discovered” the project “did not have the required permits” is false. These permits had been subject to six months of communication. As of Thursday, none were in arears, and all were “under review” by PLI.

So, too, is the implication that the city’s action would “ensure the safety of workers.” Their unions have no safety concerns about the UPMC site, and were neither consulted nor informed about the coming action. The workers want to work. They need to get paid.

In fact, leaving work unfinished has created safety hazards at the site, as projects are now being completed out of order and arrangements meant to be temporary must remain in place indefinitely. And eventually, the work that has been stopped will require other aspects of the project to slow or to stop, idling more workers.

Advertise with us

All of this could have been, and should have been, handled as it always is: by working amicably with contractors and their union partners to keep the permitting process going and workers on the job. Instead, the city needlessly threw dozens of union families into distress.

Which raises two questions: For how long? And to what end?

Two birds, one permit

The fact the work site did not open on Friday morning indicates that Mr. Gainey is not expediting the process in any meaningful way. These permits could be normalized with a stroke of a pen. And that’s exactly what must happen — by Monday.

Every day, every hour, every minute of paid work lost by union workers at the UPMC site is the responsibility of one person: Mayor Ed Gainey.

It certainly appears as if these workers have become collateral damage in the ongoing war between SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania and UPMC, in which the government of the City of Pittsburgh has been brazenly deployed by the SEIU. But as Mr. Gainey’s re-election campaign begins to kick into gear — the Mayor had a major fundraiser the evening of the stop-work order — it is also notable that the building trades have been visibly dissatisfied with their treatment under this administration. The permits strike two birds.

Regardless of the motives, however, the permit debacle demonstrates an imperious and insecure leadership style that has alienated nearly every potential partner in Pittsburgh, from developers to non-profits to unions, who are not within Mr. Gainey’s circle of trust. The resulting dysfunction is hurting workers and their families. It’s hurting Pittsburgh and its future.