The closure of both sidewalks on the essential South Negley Avenue bridge highlights the lack of progress made on deteriorating city-owned spans since the collapse of the Fern Hollow Bridge. In fact, it’s been nearly a decade since funds were first set aside for the Negley project — and yet residents must still endure emergency closures rather than celebrate long-term rehabilitation.
The Negley situation is unusually complex, but it demonstrates in microcosm both the friction all governments face in mitigating infrastructure problems, and Pittsburgh’s particular struggles in overcoming that friction.
The bridge, which turns 100 this year, had been identified for a major intervention as far back as 2013, when the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission (SPC) included 2015 and 2016 funding for the span in its Transportation Improvement Plan (TIP). But it crosses both the East Busway and railroad tracks, triggering involvement of both Pittsburgh Regional Transit and Norfolk Southern.
The latter is especially significant, because NS owns some of the substructure of the bridge — and was planning to make its Pittsburgh Line suitable for double-stacked train cars. This triggered years of negotiations and lawsuits over who would be responsible for lowering tracks and raising bridges. The South Negley project was put on hold.
Litigation was resolved in early 2022, only weeks after the Fern Hollow disaster, and the city signed a deal with Norfolk Southern to restart preliminary engineering. While no construction dates were announced, it appeared that the South Negley bridge was on its way to rehabilitation.
Not so.
In the city’s 2023 capital budget, funds planned for a 2024 project on the bridge were quietly moved to 2025. While this indicates a shift in SPC’s TIP, such a postponement is almost always made at the request of the city. In other words, despite clearing the NS hurdle in 2022, Pittsburgh didn’t expect to be ready to work until 2025 — a full decade after initial funding was approved.
But even that may be optimistic. In the Comprehensive Bridge Asset Management Program documents commissioned by the Gainey administration, there are contradictory notes about South Negley. A May 2023 report that relies on January 2023 data from the city indicates that the “vertical clearance dispute” had been resolved. But another document, dated September 2023, refers to “ongoing negotiations” between the city and NS. That report says that construction won’t begin until two years after negotiations end.
As a result, the consulting firm recommends removing Negley from the SPC’s three-year TIP, and making it part of a 12-year plan. That would mean no major movement on the bridge until at least 2027.
This story demonstrates the bureaucratic headaches and legal wrangling that make doing anything in government unreasonably difficult. But it also demonstrates Pittsburgh city government’s continuing inability to deal with this reality in a constructive way — despite the Gainey administration making the efficient improvement of the city’s bridges a top priority after the Fern Hollow collapse.
And so East Enders are left with a “protected pedestrian pathway” in the narrow road itself in order to walk between Shadyside and the bustling Centre and Baum corridor. For how long, it’s anyone’s guess.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.