From the day Nippon Steel’s surprise acquisition of U.S. Steel was announced, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has supported it as the best outcome for Pittsburgh’s — and America’s — greatest legacy corporation. Opposition to the deal has proven time and again to be political, parochial and short-sighted, more about grandstanding than weighing what’s best for Western Pennsylvania and the country as a whole.

A visit to the Post-Gazette’s North Shore newsroom on Wednesday by Takahiro Mori, Vice Chairman of Nippon Steel who is spearheading the U.S. Steel acquisition, only reassured us that there is no better option on the table for Andrew Carnegie’s company.

Closed for business?

In a detailed conversation with Post-Gazette reporter Evan Robinson-Johnson and editorial page editor Brandon McGinley, Mr. Mori described acquiring U.S. Steel as essential to Nippon’s strategy to enter the American steel market, which is the largest in the world for the “value added” steel products — such as electrical steel for advanced applications like electric vehicles — the company specializes in.

In entering the U.S. market, Mr. Mori sees Nippon’s interests as aligned with fellow U.S. steel manufacturers. When asked if he would support President Joe Biden’s move to raise steel tariffs on China, Mr. Mori replied without hesitation that he would, because what is good for American steel companies with regard to Chinese competition is good for Nippon.

Advertise with us

If the United States is once again to develop a serious industrial policy, it will have to look at each situation holistically, rather than responding with immediate suspicion to any foreign investment in American markets. That means taking into account not just who owns what, but the full reality of supply chains, domestic production capacity and geopolitical interests. The Nippon acquisition passes all these tests: The company is motivated and incentivized to enhance supply chain security and production capacity within the United States, because this is precisely the customer market it desires to access. And as a Japanese company it similarly views China as a rival, not a partner.

Strikingly, Mr. Mori observed that other business leaders in Japan, and around the world, are watching this episode closely. If cynical American politicians succeed in scuttling the deal, it will send a message around the world that the United States has turned entirely inward and views with suspicion all foreign investment — even if that investment is demonstrably good for American economic strength and independence.

Mon Valley future

The question of whether Nippon’s investment will bear fruit specifically in Pittsburgh is somewhat stickier. Mr. Mori reports that he personally committed to Governor Josh Shapiro that he would move Nippon’s North American Headquarters to Pittsburgh. As a matter of jobs, the means just a few dozen moves from Houston to Western Pennsylvania. But as a matter of taxation, moving Nippon’s American holding company to Pennsylvania could result in significant tax gains for the Commonwealth.

Mr. Mori spoke confidently about the importance of traditional integrated steel operations — that is, producing steel from scratch, as is done at U.S. Steel’s Mon Valley Works — to Nippon, and to the wider market. While “electric arc furnace” production, which makes fresh steel from scrap with fewer emissions, has become increasingly popular, from-scratch steel is higher quality and therefore essential to creating Nippon’s specialty value-added products.

Whether that steel will be made at the Mon Valley Works — which includes the Clairton Coke Works, Edgar Thomson Plant in Braddock and the Irwin Plant in West Mifflin — is less clear. Nippon is clearly open to bringing the ancient facilities into the 21st century, enhancing efficiency and reducing pollution, which would likely require an investment greater than the $1.5 billion promise canceled by U.S. Steel in 2021. But Mr. Mori said the company does not yet have enough information to know whether such an expense would be cost effective, especially compared to building a replacement facility.

Advertise with us

While the lack of a commitment is disappointing, it must be understood in context: No other U.S. Steel suitor (let alone U.S. Steel itself) was even going to consider investing in the Mon Valley. Only Nippon has the will and the resources to extend Pittsburgh’s steel legacy, and the jobs that go with it, into the future. We urge Mr. Mori to make studying the Mon Valley Works a priority, so his firm can give the region some certainty — either way — about its future.

America first

Mr. Mori indicated that he had been surprised by the extent of the political opposition to the deal. That’s in part due to his unfamiliarity with American politics — but, in truth, we have been surprised, as well.

The grandstanding behavior of both major presidential candidates and both of Pennsylvania’s senators has been cynical and disappointing. They have pretended to put America’s and Pennsylvania’s interests first, while actually putting their own interests first by stoking uninformed and xenophobic suspicions, rather than performing reasoned analysis.

Similarly, the United Steelworkers has served its image but not its members by attempting to obstruct the deal. The union’s preferred suitor, Cleveland-Cliffs, would pay far less and result in several redundancies and anti-trust vulnerabilities. USW bosses might be more comfortable with Cleveland-Cliffs, but that match would result in thousands of lost jobs, especially in Pittsburgh.

Mr. Mori has come to understand American politics well enough to know that the deal’s political status will change after November 5, no matter who wins the White House. Election year incentives will fade, and hopefully good sense will prevail.

And hopefully by this time next year, the acquisition of U.S. Steel by Nippon Steel will be complete, and we can look forward to strengthening Pittsburgh’s, and America’s, legacy of steel.