The Gainey administration’s scheme to squeeze taxes out of currently tax exempt properties — including, shockingly, Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh — was badly conceived from the beginning, and has been executed with breathtaking dishonesty and incompetence. Everyone involved should be ashamed of their role in this farce, from Mayor Ed Gainey and Solicitor Krysia Kubiak to the out-of-town contract attorneys to whom Pittsburgh taxpayers have (so far) coughed up $400,000.
This is a new low for a mayoral administration that seems determined to test just how bad governance can get before voters finally lash out.
No strategy
At Wednesday’s press conference, Mr. Gainey and Ms. Kubiak announced the results of a full year of work: a new tranche of 104 nonprofit parcels the administration is challenging as part of its plan to get a “fair share” of taxes from Pittsburgh’s large nonprofit sector. A decade ago, a court dismissed a city lawsuit seeking to strip health care conglomerate UPMC as a whole of its tax exempt status. Now, the administration hopes they can succeed by challenging nonprofit real estate piecemeal.
The problem is that instead of fighting one lawsuit each against juggernauts, the city would be fighting dozens, all at once, each likely to get bogged down in state courts for years. Actually scoring victories would require strategically selecting the properties with the least discernible public purposes.
Instead, the city challenged the entirety of Children’s Hospital, Allegheny General Hospital, the Magee-Women’s Research Institute and a pair of nursing homes. Also among the challenges: CHP medical offices in Lawrenceville; a Western Psych addiction recovery center in Lincoln-Lemington; an urgent care facility in Bloomfield; and part of the UPMC Forbes Tower offices in Oakland that were already unsuccessfully challenged last year.
These quixotic challenges artificially inflated the potential tax haul described by Ms. Kubiak at the press event. She claimed the city could see $6.5 million a year if all the challenges were successful, but CHP and AGH alone account for $4.8 million, or 74% of those potential revenues. Add in other examples of medical and research offices — as well as Pitt’s outdoor athletics stadiums — and you get to $5.5 million, or 85% of challenged revenue — dead on arrival.
One-percent success
This same process played out last year. Then, Ms. Kubiak promised City Council up to $3.5 million in annual tax revenues. First, the actual tax bills for the 26 challenged properties only added up to $600,000, so she inflated the potential by 500% right away. Second, the challenges the city actually won only added up to about $70,000. (Ms. Kubiak inflated this to $100,000 on Wednesday.)
But there’s more: The vast majority of those meager results are from two parking garages at Pitt and CMU, which both institutions are currently appealing. They will likely prevail — it’s hard to run a college if students, staff and visitors can’t park — and if they do, the city’s tax haul from last year’s challenges will drop to under $5,000.
The maximum reasonable revenue from this year’s challenges is about $1 million, not $6.5 million. But, again, the vast majority of that — over $900,000 — is parking for museums, colleges and hospitals. Even if those succeed at the Office of Property Assessments, they will be challenged for years by institutions who argue, compellingly, that parking is essential to their public charitable missions.
To make matters worse, the parking challenges are inconsistent, indicating a clear targeting of UPMC. At Magee, each one of over a dozen tiny parcels that make up the garage for the Research Institute are challenged. At Allegheny Health Network’s West Penn Hospital, only individual slivers of parking lots are challenged.
Mixed messages
All told, the administration’s best bets are vacant land and buildings whose tax bills add up to around $60,000 per year, or less than 1% of Ms. Kubiak’s $6.5 million figure. Now compare that to the $400,000 the city has already paid to national law firm Loeb & Loeb LLP, and the money the city will pay the firm in the future.
Adding to the confusion, the solicitor has delivered mixed messages about what that money is for.
In City Council last October, Ms. Kubiak told members they should approve an increase in the Loeb & Loeb contract from $150,000 to $400,000 because the city’s law and finance staff didn’t have the time to thoroughly vet tens of thousands of parcels. But at Wednesday’s event, she told reporters that the city mostly needed outside counsel for “strategy and advice,” and that city workers had been able to handle the properties largely on their own.
That’s a massive waste of city employees’ time, and that’s a lot of money for some very bad strategy and advice. If council has any dignity left, it must not approve any more taxpayer dollars for this delusional quest.
An embarrassment
Mr. Gainey and his team are right about one thing: Pittsburgh’s enormous nonprofit sector needs to pay its fair share to support city services. But this irrational and incompetent scheme isn’t the way to reach that goal.
What Mr. Gainey needs to do is the same thing he needed to do from day one, and that he promised to do during his campaign: get the region’s major nonprofit leaders in a room and iron out a fair way to calculate contributions to the city’s general fund. This is what UPMC, the elephant in the room, has long said it wants, and would respond favorably to. Test that promise by convening a meeting and offering a fair bargain.
That would be real leadership. But what we have instead is one of the most embarrassing and wasteful deployments of public power in Pittsburgh’s history. Everybody outside Mr. Gainey’s shrinking inner circle is laughing. And the people of Pittsburgh are paying.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.