During last week’s Allegheny County Council meeting, the time occupied by public commenters on the war in Gaza — including those carelessly (at best) evoking antisemitic tropes — dwarfed that spent debating actual county policies. While citizens have a right to speak their minds, and in particular a right to petition their elected officials, the people as a whole have a right to legislative bodies that actually conduct the people’s business.
County Council is not, and cannot be allowed to become, a freewheeling debate society on issues that have nothing to do with Allegheny County. Council President Pat Catena should not allow this issue to fester: He should allow a Gaza cease-fire resolution to come to a vote at the next council meeting on March 5, where in all likelihood it will fail. Then Council can and must put foreign affairs in the rear-view mirror.
Agitation for cease-fire resolutions has become commonplace in local governments around the country. As in Allegheny County, the advocacy has often taken the form of an implicit threat: Activists will bombard legislators with messages and hijack public meetings until the body passes a resolution calling for a cease-fire, and directly or indirectly accusing Israel of grave crimes.
Last week, for instance, County Council spent only a few minutes debating an important tax abatement for Downtown office-to-residential conversions, then listened to hours of commentary about a war in the Levant over which it has no authority. This is not a responsible use of public time.
These resolutions, of course, have no practical effect on American policy, which is set by the president and Congress. What they do accomplish, by trying to capture the county government on a national political matter — to make Allegheny County officially pro-Palestine or pro-Israel — is to divide communities, and to stigmatize those who disagree.
The activists who spoke believe that Israel has mistreated the Palestinians since the nation's beginning, and is now inhumanely brutal and perhaps genocidal. Others, especially Jewish Pittsburghers, for whom the state of Israel is a source of hope in a world that has tried to annihilate them several times, believe Hamas is a lethal and implacable threat.
This is not a dispute that County Council — or any local government — is competent to resolve. Whatever good condemning one side or another might do, the harm it does to the communities local elected officials actually serve outweighs that good.
The debate over how the state of Israel has prosecuted the war in Gaza, and over the merits of a temporary or permanent cease-fire, is a crucial one. But Allegheny County Council is not the place to have that debate, especially when it is marked by careless speech that evokes ancient prejudices and stigmatizes people of good faith.
The March 5 meeting should be the last time the word “cease-fire” is uttered in council chambers for a very long time.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.