The City of Pittsburgh’s finances are in far worse condition than any city official has publicly acknowledged, and than the Post-Gazette Editorial Board had known in our urgent warnings before City Council approved Mayor Ed Gainey’s budget in December. Due to the collapse of assessed commercial real estate values and a state court’s invalidation of a nearly 20-year-old city tax, under the current plan Pittsburgh’s financial reserves could be completely depleted within the next two years.

Barring a massive tax increase or brutal austerity measures in next year’s budget, Pittsburgh will likely drop below its own legally mandated minimum reserves — 10% of expenditures — as soon as the end of this year, depending on how quickly tax refunds come due. We had previously warned this might happen in 2026 or 2027.

Worse, given the budget’s unrealistic revenue projections, even this year’s nearly $30 million projected operating surplus could easily be wiped out, leading to the first of three consecutive years of deficits that trigger Act 47 state oversight of city finances — again. It’s even possible the day of reckoning might come sooner: The city may not be able to make payroll, which would also trigger Act 47, by the end of 2025.

It would be a historic collapse. While the Gainey administration inherited, or has been otherwise not responsible for, some of the key contributing factors to this crisis, it does have a responsibility to confront the situation honestly. Thus far, it has not been willing to do so.

Advertise with us

Budget basics

A municipal budget is a complicated instrument. But here are the key numbers to understand the fundamentals of Pittsburgh’s problems.

At the end of 2023, the city had about $160 million in its reserve fund, and the 2024 budget projects $140 million at the end of this year. That’s healthy: The legal minimum is 10% of expenditures, or about $70 million.

The Gainey-City Council five-year projection sees those reserves dwindling to $80 million. This is typical: Elected officials don’t want to give the impression of austerity, so project generous spending into the future. This can work, as long as revenue estimates are conservative.

But they aren’t.

Not only is Pittsburgh faced with at least $15 million per year in revenue shortfalls, it’s possibly facing $100 million in tax refunds owned to property owners and, strangely, professional athletes.

Advertise with us

Refund checks

Current appeals of commercial real estate values are retroactive to 2022 and 2023, during which the ratio used to determine assessed values from market values was artificially inflated. This means two years of refunds on high-vacancy office towers.

Estimating the tax loss is challenging, with some calculations as high as $35 million per year, based on a 20% reduction across the board, and higher reductions Downtown. We’ll take a more conservative approach and apply the average of 35% reductions, based on the five skyscrapers already reported, to the 23% of the city’s taxable value located in the Golden Triangle. Then we’ll assume other commercial losses across the city are offset by rising values elsewhere. The result is refunds of $24 million, and an annual tax loss of $12 million.

And then there’s the “jock tax.” Starting in 2005, the city levied a 3% “facility usage fee” on all non-resident athletes and entertainers who ply their trade in a major venue in Pittsburgh.

While these kinds of taxes were briefly in vogue, they’ve been successfully challenged across the country. In Sep. 2022, the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas ruled that Pittsburgh’s “fee” was really a tax that violated the state constitution by discriminating against non-residents.

But Pittsburgh has continued to collect the tax during appeals — and has used it in projections to balance the budget, to the tune of more than $4 million per year. Just last month, however, the Commonwealth Court ruled against the city. This week, the city asked the state Supreme Court to hear the case, and it’s not inconceivable the city could prevail. But balancing the budget based on this kind of speculation is imprudent, if not fraudulent.

Advertise with us

Worse, if the jock tax is unconstitutional now, it was unconstitutional in 2005. In other cases around the country, this has triggered refunds — with interest — because the government can’t benefit from an unconstitutional tax. The amount Pittsburgh has collected since 2005? Over $70 million.

Facing reality

The conservatively estimated $24 million in property tax refunds plus $70 million and interest in jock tax refunds easily gets to $100 million. (There is a chance, due to the unusual construction of the jock tax law, that the city could recoup one-third, but this would still mean paying back nearly $50 million plus interest.) Even if the city managed to spread out the damage over a few years, the reserves would still be drained.

When you add in the roughly $15 million in annual property tax losses, that more than wipes out the $115 million in reserves projected at the end of 2025. Before the end of the year, the city wouldn’t be able to make payroll.

And this analysis doesn’t even include the budget’s wildly unrealistic projections of $16 million per year in interest income. As the reserves are drained, that, too, will go to zero.

The only way out will be massive tax increases (or new taxes), or massive cuts to the city’s workforce and services — neither of which Mr. Gainey will want to propose leading up to the 2025 elections.

Indeed, it looks more than ever like the administration is hoping to conceal this crisis just long enough to get through the Democratic primary. That means it will be up to City Council, as well as smart new City Controller Rachael Heisler, to sound the alarm. Unless the city makes an honest accounting of this grim financial reality, it will place itself once again at the cruel mercy of state oversight.