These are serious times in the City of Pittsburgh. But the city is led by unserious people.
Councilwoman Erika Strassburger and outgoing Councilman Bruce Kraus have proposed, and have already wasted council’s precious time and attention in preparing, three bills that will accomplish absolutely nothing, except driving a few small businesses out of the city. The two humanitarians would like to ban furs, foie gras and horse-drawn carriages within city limits.
This, at a time when the safety of actual human beings in Pittsburgh, whether due to crime or unsafe streets or a lack of homelessness services, is a major and growing concern; when council should be poring over a proposed budget whose misleading projections will place the city under state supervision by the end of the decade; and when council has been repeatedly hoodwinked by a rogue mayoral administration whose penchant for no-bid contracts, rubber-stamped by the city’s legislature, is under investigation by law enforcement.
And then this past weekend, after a Post-Gazette editorial revealed troubling information about the city’s handling of the $8 million Jim Rogers settlement, City Council President Theresa Kail-Smith — one of the only adults in the room — moved to halt all payments until council investigated the matter. In late October, council had blindly approved a $10,000 payment to a medical pathologist who had already served as an expert against the city in the same case — but members only became aware and concerned after media uncovered it.
Council’s excuse for its negligence is that it doesn’t have the resources to investigate every bill the Mayor’s Office sends to be paid. Fair enough. But then, why are some members spending what few resources they have on boutique causes like furs and fatty goose liver?
And to make matters worse, the ordinance’s sponsors didn’t even have the decency to contact the city’s premier furrier, Carl Herrmann, before moving to condemn and destroy his family’s legacy. The bill would drive Mr. Herrmann’s business, which has been Downtown for over a century, out of the city by the end of next year.
Of course these bills won’t save any animals. Fur shops will just move to the suburbs. The foie gras industry won’t notice and won’t change. And horses with the few carriage operations in the city? They won’t be set free to roam the West. Most likely, they’ll be slaughtered.
Meanwhile, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals has claimed the University of Pittsburgh has committed dozens of violations of federal animal welfare law in recent years. If councilors really want to protect animals, we can point them in the right direction.
But of course this isn’t actually about animals. It’s about politicians vainly patting themselves on the back. All while Pittsburgh undergoes its worst political crisis in decades.
The three ordinances will be considered at Wednesday’s standing committee meeting. They should be summarily dismissed, so council can focus on actually serving the people by stewarding taxpayer dollars and holding the executive branch accountable.
But that would require a majority of serious people interested in governing. And that’s a luxury, like furs and foie gras, Pittsburgh may not have.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.