While the City of Pittsburgh has insisted that developers set aside substantial numbers of new residential units for affordable housing, the city has failed to spend over $40 million in federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds allocated to affordable housing. Despite running on an affordable housing platform, Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration has lagged behind the affordable housing benchmarks set by his predecessor — while holding up development projects with demands for affordable units.
The city is struggling to add both market-rate and affordable residences, exacerbating nationwide trends in the housing market that have made it difficult for people below the middle class — and even people in the middle class — to find decent housing. There’s nothing wrong with attaching affordable housing requirements to market-rate developments, but all by itself it is not an effective affordable housing policy — especially while the city’s own federal COVID relief funds go unspent.
Squandered inheritance
The Gainey administration inherited a little more than $41 million in ARPA funds set aside for “housing support” by former Mayor Bill Peduto. Mr. Gainey, with City Council’s approval, has moved some of that money onto different line items, reflecting his administration’s priorities, which is his prerogative. He has kept the total figure of $41 million constant.
The problem is that, as of the most recent disclosure dated June 30, the city has only spent about $800,000 — roughly 2%. All the ARPA funds must be firmly allocated by the end of 2024 and spent by the end of 2026 or the city will lose them. Besides the generally vague line items on the disclosure spreadsheets, there is no public plan for spending the affordable housing allocations.
At the same time the administration has struggled to spend its federal allocation, Mr. Gainey’s Urban Redevelopment Authority proposed, and City Council approved, spending $62.5 million over 25 years to buy up to only $42 million in debt to use for affordable housing. This put taxpayers on the hook for possibly tens of millions in debt service — all while another $41 million in federal grants sits fallow.
Moving money, but not spending it
The Peduto administration originally set aside ARPA funds for affordable housing, mostly focusing on enhancing low- and moderate-income homeownership in the city, in four categories: community land trust grants ($5 million), the OwnPGH homeownership support program ($21.5 million), a utilities and weatherization program to lower costs and energy use for low-income homeowners ($10 million) and protection of “naturally occurring affordable housing” (NOAH) from market fluctuations ($5 million).
- Community land trusts allow non-profit organizations to own the land beneath a house and to place encumbrances on the deed that ensure the house itself can only be purchased by people below certain income thresholds. For instance, a URA-backed CLT currently exists in Lawrenceville to protect some homes from the consistently rising prices in the neighborhood. None of the $5 million allocation has been spent.
- OwnPGH offers grants and loans to first-time homebuyers in the city under certain income levels, while also building new units set aside for first-time homebuyers. The Gainey administration reduced the original $21.5 million set-aside to $15.6 million, and has spent $700,000.
- The weatherization program, which was part of the Peduto administration’s broader climate initiatives, would have provided grants to homeowners to save on utilities by keeping their homes cooler in hot weather and warmer in cold weather. The original allocation of $10 million is now $4 million, and none has been spent.
- Mr. Gainey has increased the $5 million set aside to keep currently affordable housing available for low-income households to $8.9 million. However, none has been spent.
Lastly, the Gainey administration has created three new ARPA line items: office space conversion ($2.1 million), education and counseling ($1.4 million) and affordable development through the Pittsburgh Housing Development Corporation ($4 million). Only about $100,000, through PHDC, has been spent.
Falling behind
Mr. Gainey has always been correct that a lack of affordable housing is a problem for Pittsburgh, and that the city has a role to play in fixing it. However, his administration has shown little interest in the complicated work of actually fixing it — all while taking out expensive taxpayer-financed debt that serves only to signal to his supporters that he is serious about affordable housing.
The proof, after all, is in the results. Despite an unprecedented federal windfall, in its first year the Gainey administration created or preserved affordable housing at about half the rate the Peduto administration did in its last two years.
One area where Mr. Gainey has followed through is in making big demands of private developers to include affordable housing in their plans. This has only had the effect, however, of slowing the expansion of both affordable and market-rate housing in the city, pricing out more people.
It is standard to lump Mr. Gainey in with the wave of progressive politicians who have been swept into office here in recent years. And, among some progressives, it is standard to regard criticism of Mr. Gainey as a sign of reactionary tendencies.
But as a matter of results — not just rhetoric — this administration has delivered far less for progressives, on affordable housing among other issues, than its predecessor. And at 20 months since inauguration, the honeymoon is long since over.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.