Pennsylvania is one of only 13 states with no limit on how young a juvenile can be tried in adult court and exposed to adult jails and prisons. In Lawrence County in 2009, for example, 11-year-old Jordan Brown was charged in adult court for the fatal shooting of his father’s fiancee. He was too young to shave but faced a mandatory life sentence.

The case was later transferred to juvenile court, before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court overturned the conviction in 2018, citing a lack of evidence. Even so, the case highlighted Pennsylvania’s harsh juvenile laws. Before the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2012 that life-without-parole sentences for juveniles are unconstitutional, Pennsylvania prisons held more than 500 juvenile lifers — the highest number in the nation.

Most juvenile lifers in Pennsylvania have been resentenced or released, but Pennsylvania state prisons, with nearly 39,000 inmates, still hold almost 1,000 people who were sentenced as juveniles, the Department of Corrections reported this week.

Not surprisingly, the effects of Pennsylvania’s juvenile laws have been skewed by race. In 2018, Black males accounted for 7% of Pennsylvania's youth population (ages 10-17), but 56% of youth charged and convicted as adults, the Pennsylvania Juvenile Justice Task Force reported. Racial disparities have been even more stark in Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

Under a so-called direct-file law passed by Pennsylvania legislators in 1995, juveniles, ages 15-17, are automatically charged as adults for certain serious offenses, such as aggravated assault. For murder, adult charges are mandatory at any age. In Pittsburgh last month, 15-year-old Jaymier Perry was automatically charged as an adult in the fatal shooting of 16-year-old Derrick Harris. He, too, could face a potential life sentence.

Super-predator hysteria

Pennsylvania legislators passed the mandatory direct-file statute when many other states also were expanding laws that removed children from juvenile courts and placed them in the adult system. These laws were fueled by a racially coded hysteria during the 1990s that predicted a looming wave of young, vicious and remorseless “super-predators.”

The prediction of a super-predator epidemic was a costly mistake. So were the juvenile laws it inspired, including Pennsylvania’s automatic direct-file statute. It’s time to undo that law and let judges decide, based on individual circumstances, whether to try a juvenile in adult court.

Pennsylvania House Democrats plan to re-introduce legislation this year, sponsored by Rep. Christopher Rabb, D-Philadelphia, which would, among other things, end automatic direct-file charging for juveniles. Legislators should approve the bill, and include a provision that would raise the minimum age for trying a juvenile in adult court to 16, as California has done.

Advertise with us

Maintaining a distinct juvenile and adult justice system is essential to enabling young people to become productive adults. The juvenile system offers more educational and rehabilitative services. Youth serving time in the adult system are also victimized by older prisoners and sexually abused. They suffer long-term psychological damage and are far more likely to re-offend after they’re released.

Juveniles more unstable

The U.S. Supreme Court has established that children and adults have different standards of legal accountability. In 2005, the high court banned the death penalty for juveniles; in 2012, it struck down mandatory life sentences for juveniles.

Juveniles don't have the same legal rights and responsibilities as adults because they lack the maturity and judgment to handle them. Nor should they suffer the same consequences.

“Social science and neurological science have clearly shown that kids are different than adults and should not be treated in the same way,” Marsha Levick, chief legal officer for the Juvenile Law Center in Philadelphia, told a Post-Gazette editor on Tuesday. “They’re not as blameworthy, and they have a large capacity to change as they grow older.”

Advertise with us

Brain imaging research shows teenage brains are more impulsive and unstable than adult brains — even without the abuse and neglect many young people have suffered. Scientists now recognize that the brain and, with it, inhibitions to act are not fully developed until well into the 20s.

Happily, the number of children charged and adjudicated as adults in Pennsylvania has decreased. It dropped 56% between 2009 and 2018, from 752 to 332. That suggests courts are exercising more care in handling juvenile cases in which they have discretion.

Even so, one-size-fits-all laws on charging juveniles, without considering individual circumstances, make just outcomes more difficult. For a more effective, fair, compassionate and rational juvenile justice system, Pennsylvania must raise the minimum age for trying juveniles as adults, and eliminate automatic adult charges for children.