In Highland Park this month, Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey called out his predecessors for making false promises to residents about fixing a loud and disruptive open-air police firing range in Lincoln-Lemington. It was a curious accusation, considering the Gainey Administration had scuttled, or at least delayed, a workable plan to construct a major public safety training campus, including a quiet indoor range, near the current range.
That plan, inherited from the administration of former Mayor Bill Peduto, remains the safest, healthiest and most practical option. The Gainey Administration should get it back on track.
Mixed messages
In his first budget, for 2023, Mr. Gainey pushed back $17 million in expected 2024 and 2025 allocations for planning, design and early construction of a public safety training campus and indoor range. He also — with City Council approval — drained the account by raiding the $1.4 million that had been already set aside for the project.

Making matters worse, Mr. Gainey’s team can’t get its story straight. In March, press secretary Maria Montaño said the training facility’s scope had been narrowed from all public safety operations — police, fire, EMS and animal control — to a police-only training center. But at the Highland Park meeting a month later, Office of Management and Budget Director Jake Pawlak said the administration plans “to build a joint public safety training facility, including a range, that will solve this issue.”
At the very same meeting, Mr. Gainey said, “I'm not going to be the mayor to come up here and tell you, as previous mayors have done, we got it, we got it, we got it. We can't have it if there's no plan.”
That’s three members of the Gainey Administration with three different stories. The public deserves a straight answer.
A 40-year-old nuisance
Pittsburgh is the only city its size whose police train at an open-air firing range within earshot of residential neighborhoods. More than 30 years ago, in 1989, a noise consultant concluded, after testing the sound generated by a single firearm, that “corrective action” was needed.
Since then, nothing has changed, while community opposition has grown, along with worries about the range’s impact on public health — especially for people with conditions such as post-traumatic stress disorder and those affected directly or indirectly by gun violence.
Sound from the range, tucked into the hillside on the east side of Washington Boulevard, easily crosses the Negley Run valley and saturates Highland Park — both the park and the neighborhood. The tat-tat-tat of gunfire also reverberates in the residential portions of Lincoln-Lemington, forcing some people to stay inside their homes while the range is in use.
After decades of paralysis, the city must fix this threat to public health and quality-of-life.
A plan in shambles
Contrary to what Mr. Gainey has suggested, there was a plan to fix the problem. For nearly a decade, city officials have eyed the closed Veterans Administration hospital on the hilltop in Lincoln-Lemington. In 2018, Mr. Peduto set aside funds to turn the site into a public safety training center. After a three-year process, the federal government donated the property to the city in 2021.
Besides consolidating the city’s public safety training and administration facilities, the campus would have generated revenue as a regional training center. It would have also allowed the closure of separate facilities, saving nearly $2 million per year in leases on police facilities; allowing for the sale of EMS headquarters on valuable Shadyside land; and clearing the way for essential flood control projects on the site of the fire training center on Washington Boulevard.
The Peduto Administration had not secured funding for the entire project, but the plan could have attracted state and federal grants. Even after the Gainey Administration’s setbacks, the plan remains a viable option that the mayor’s team ought to advance.
Mr. Gainey is not bound to see through all his predecessor’s plans. But when he scuttles one, especially one as large and promising as this one, he owes the people of Pittsburgh an explanation — one that his staff won’t contradict.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.