Pennsylvania’s four state-related universities, including the University of Pittsburgh, receive hundreds of millions of dollar in state tax dollars. Nevertheless, they are covered far less rigorously under state Right-to-Know laws than are the 10 universities in the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education.
The principles of transparency and openness ought to apply to all institutions of higher education that receive public money. Operating openly will become even more important as state-related universities — Penn State, Pitt, Temple and Lincoln — request more state funding to restrain tuition increases.
Gov. Josh Shapiro has proposed a 7% increase in state funding for those schools, compared to 2% for the 10 state system universities. Together, the four state-related schools would receive more than $600 million in state funding, if legislators approve the governor’s proposal.
“State-related universities receive a significant amount of public money, and have a significant impact on the people of Pennsylvania,” said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association. “Public money, and their vital public role, demand that they operate in an accountable and transparent manner.”
Greater state investment
Even with a 7% increase in state funding, state-related university presidents told legislators last month they couldn’t commit to a tuition freeze. In an interview with Maddie Aiken of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Pitt’s incoming chancellor, Joan Gabel, called for a “vigorous state investment” for the University of Pittsburgh.
Ms. Gabel is right. Pennsylvania ranks near the bottom in state investment in higher education — and near the top in levels of student debt. Pitt charges $19,000 for in-state tuition; the average amount of debt for students leaving Pitt is $38,000.
With a greater financial investment, however, legislators should demand more openness in how state-related universities operate. At a hearing last month before the House Appropriations Committee, Rep. Ryan Warner, R-Fayette, said that, without greater transparency from state-related universities, he would not support the governor’s proposal to increase their state funding.
The issue stepped to the fore this month, when Pitt named Ms. Gabel, the current president of the University of Minnesota, as Pitt’s new chancellor. Her contract was not made public; nor, under state law, did it have to be. The law requires state-related universities to report direct financial compensation to top administrators, but not perks, incentives and other benefits. Chancellor-elect Gabel will live, as have previous chancellors, in a university-owned and -provided Colonial Revival-style mansion in the Shadyside neighborhood of Pittsburgh.
Ms. Gabel, who will start at Pitt in July, will earn a base salary of $950,000, with five annual $200,000 deferred retention incentive payments. She will be eligible for $100,000 retention payments on the third, fourth and fifth anniversary of her start date, and entitled to a $5,000 reimbursement for any tax complications arising from her move to Pennsylvania.
The contract may lay out additional incentives, but those are shielded from the public.
Expanding transparency
State-related universities have preferred to operate in in the dark. In 2007, they fought hard to persuade legislators to exempt them entirely from the state’s Right-to-Know statute. They ended up, for no compelling reason, with a partial exemption. Now, legislators should put state-related universities entirely under the Right-to-Know law. Under the law, a member of the public can, if denied a record or document, file an appeal to the state Office of Open Records.
Several legislators — including Republican Doug Mastriano and Democrat Vincent Hughes in the State Senate — have introduced bills that would expand transparency in state-related universities. In the state House, Democrats Christopher Raab and Darisha Parker plan to introduce bills that also would require state-related universities to make more information public.
Bringing Pennsylvania’s four state-related universities under Right-to-Know would bring a fractured system of higher education a small step closer to a unified system that could better serve the state’s nearly 400,000 public university and college students.
As pressures mount for a greater public investment in higher education, Pennsylvania’s major universities must respond with more openness and accountability. Without more information, the people can’t determine how well state-related universities are performing and maintaining access with the resources they have. A new level of transparency includes bringing into the light the spiraling costs of compensation contracts granted university chancellors and presidents.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.