Ubiquitous smartphones and social media have inflicted serious mental health problems on young people. A lawsuit filed by Pittsburgh Public Schools on April 6 against tech companies, however, is an ineffective solution.
Instead of legal action, the city’s school district should focus on how to reduce students’ use of social media. Broader reform is best done through the legislature, not the courts: PPS should ask the General Assembly to enact reasonable legislation to mitigate the harm done by social media companies, as have other state governments.
Mental health data on young Americans — especially girls — is startling and unequivocal. Nearly a third of high school girls considered attempting suicide in 2021, with one in seven actually attempting it. Three out of five feel persistently helpless and alone — a 20% increase in the last decade.
The steepest rises in despair and anxiety among high school students correlate to the growth of social media. Adolescence has always been a challenging time, as hormones course through changing bodies and young people struggle to understand the world and their place in it. Social media supercharge those stresses and emotions by increasing, exponentially, the opportunities for petty cruelty. Exposing tender psyches to magnified shame and judgment can unsettle even well-adjusted adults.
The Pittsburgh Public School Board rightly regards social media as addicting and a threat to educational development. But proving a causal link between the conduct of social media companies and mental health would be much harder to do in court than demonstrating the heath risks of tobacco.
That doesn’t mean PPS is powerless. Instead of litigating, the district should develop curricula and regulations that alert young people to the dangers of social media, and make devices harder to use during school hours. Teachers should at least have the authority, and support, to collect phones from their students at the beginning of class.
As for government policy, Utah has developed the nation’s strictest laws, requiring social media sites to verify the age of all users and exclude kids 17 and under from using the apps between 10:30 p.m. and 6:30 a.m. Utah also requires social media companies to allow parents access to their children’s accounts. France has proposed extending an outright ban on porn sites for kids under 15 to all social media services, without parental consent.
Pennsylvania lawmakers need not go as far as Utah or France. Children need certain privacy rights for their mental health and development.
The government, however, also has legitimate interests in regulating social media companies to protect the mental health of children. It should be clear by now that social media companies, focused on little but their bottom lines, won’t do it themselves.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.