Advocates for Pennsylvania’s public universities, aiming to make a quality college education accessible, worry that Gov. Josh Shapiro’s first budget shortchanges state-owned universities and will lead to tuition increases, as well as, among other things, inadequate funding for high-demand fields.

They should worry. Mr. Shapiro’s proposed 2% increase, for example, for the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education, one of four networks of publicly funded universities, isn’t enough: It does not include money the 85,000-student system needs to freeze tuition, now at $7,716, for a fifth straight year; nor does it include money to reduce annual tuition costs for education majors in a state that desperately needs K-12 teachers. Pennsylvania’s college graduates already carry the nation’s third-highest student debt.

Unhappily, financial pressures on the entire system of state-funded universities will only increase, unless the state shows a far greater financial commitment. But institutions of higher education throughout this four-tiered system must also do all they can to operate efficiently and effectively, without compromising access or academic quality.

Up to now, entrenched politics and parochial interests have blocked wholesale reform: Public higher education in Pennsylvania needs restructuring, despite the good work many universities have done on internal reforms and smaller-scale cooperative agreements.

Advertise with us

A fractured system

Aside from 129 private colleges, Pennsylvania now has four competing and overlapping networks; each receives public funding and has champions in the legislature. These sometimes duplicative and competitive efforts are no longer sustainable for students, taxpayers, or the institutions, especially given enrollment declines and uncertain state funding. Among other things, a more centralized system would reduce administrators, which are growing faster than faculty members.

Mr. Shapiro asked his acting Education Secretary Khalid Mumin to convene institution leaders to craft a reform plan. Other governors, notably Gov. Tom Corbett in 2012, have tried the same approach and failed to get results. With college presidents defending their own turfs, nothing gets done.

Instead, an independent commission, including stakeholders such as students and parents, operating with full transparency, ought to examine the entire arena of public higher education and recommend changes, followed by a robust public comment period.

Illinois and Texas have already benefited from citizen-led commissions. Given the inevitable resistance that a more coordinated and unified system would trigger, the Shapiro Administration will need sharp elbows and political skills to move any plan along. Any commission or administration managing this process will have to answer tough questions about potential job losses, changes to student learning, and economic impacts to communities.

Advertise with us

A statewide perspective

Many states, including New York and Wisconsin, already operate state universities in a more coordinated and unified manner. Leaders of the Pennsylvania system have discussed similar options, but not seriously.

Now, the state’s four networks include the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education. That’s a misnomer: It is not a comprehensive statewide system, but a collection of former teacher training colleges that have evolved into full-fledged universities. Chancellor Daniel Greenstein and his staff have done excellent work to upgrade these universities, but that work has mostly focused internally, without a statewide perspective.

The 10 state system universities include the Western Pennsylvania campuses of PennWest University (California, Clarion and Edinboro), as well as Indiana University of Pennsylvania and Slippery Rock University. State system tuition is less than half that of state-related universities, which include the University of Pittsburgh and Penn State University.

Another network is the branch system of Penn State University, with 24 convenient campuses around the state.

Advertise with us

A special category called state-related universities makes up the third network. Four institutions – Penn State, Pitt, Lincoln, and Temple — receive state support directed at lowering tuition costs for Pennsylvania residents.

The fourth group consists of 15 community colleges to serve the state’s 67 counties. Other states have more of these affordable and accessible two-year institutions, which traditionally serve as gateways to post-secondary education for many low-income students. In Pennsylvania, however, these colleges have suffered, due to competition from the other three tiers of higher education.

During his recent budget address Gov. Shapiro said Pennsylvania’s higher education system isn’t working. He’s right, but previous governors have said the same, without bringing reforms or improvements.

Bringing fundamental change to Pennsylvania’s dysfunctional system of state-funded higher education will be arduous and challenging. For the sake of the state’s future, however, now is the time to start.