A year after the catastrophic failure of the Frick Park bridge that carried Forbes Avenue over the Fern Hollow ravine, a new span has replaced it. Nothing else, however, has changed: Complacency and incompetence still define Mayor Ed Gainey’s policies and practices on repairing and maintaining the city’s crumbling bridges.

The Post-Gazette reported Friday that none of the city’s 32 other bridges rated “poor” have been improved since the Fern Hollow collapse. Worse, none are scheduled to be repaired this year. Pittsburgh city officials have done nothing to reflect the urgency they expressed a year ago. The city’s Comprehensive Bridge Management Program, created by Mr. Gainey, was a good first step, but we have little confidence he will see those plans through.

The mayor, city council members and the city’s bureaucracy have shown little interest in fixing the city’s failures in Fern Hollow. No one has been held to account. Until a few months ago, the city did not even have a master list of its bridges and their conditions. (An experienced private firm is now developing a detailed plan for each span.) The only serious investigations into the collapse, aside from news media reports, are coming from the federal government.

The commission that wasn’t

Advertise with us

Perhaps the most encouraging response from the city immediately following the disaster was then-Councilman Corey O’Connor’s proposed Commission on Infrastructure Asset Reporting and Investment. The commission was to advise the mayor, city council and the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure, including identifying “the full scope of investment needed to achieve and maintain a state of good repair of City assets.” Council passed the ordinance on March 1, and Mayor Gainey signed it two days later.

Creating a single group with the expertise to take a comprehensive view of the city’s infrastructure would relieve the city of relying on the byzantine bureaucracy whose incompetence was exposed in the Frick Park rubble. Nearly 11 months later, however, the Commission on Infrastructure Asset Reporting and Investment hasn’t met. In fact, the mayor hasn’t appointed a single member. Nor have City Council’s calendar or minutes mentioned it.

By not filling the seats on its flagship commission, the Gainey Administration has underscored its failure to deliver the quiet but substantive leadership it promised city residents.

Incompetence and nonchalance

The Post-Gazette revealed last summer that the city had failed to advocate for its infrastructure needs before the Southwest Pennsylvania Commission, the metropolitan planning organization that distributes federal transportation dollars. Dollars that should have repaired and restored bridges in Pittsburgh went, instead, to the county and other local municipalities. Pittsburgh has announced no reforms or accelerated any bridge construction schedules. Some of the worst bridges, like the Charles Anderson Bridge that carries the Boulevard of the Allies over Panther Hollow in Oakland, still have more than two years to wait just for bidding to begin.

Advertise with us

The Robert McAfee Bridge, which carries California Avenue over a ravine between Marshall-Shadeland and Brighton Heights, is another case-in-point. Hunks of metal fall daily off the bridge into the valley below, where business owner Marcie Kemmler has begged the city for help. Last summer, the mayor’s office promised a net to catch the debris, but hasn’t delivered.

Only after media coverage, including in the Post-Gazette, did the city return to Ms. Kemmler’s valley. A representative from the city promised “preliminary design” had begun to get a “pricing estimate” to submit for approval. Then, maybe, in “several more weeks,” there would be nets to catch the falling metal. But only under the sidewalks, not the entire bridge.

The sound of silence

Despite the problems and risks, Mayor Ed Gainey has refused to answer questions about his administration’s plans and progress in repairing Pittsburgh’s crumbling infrastructure. This indefensible silence long predates the newspaper’s labor dispute, which started in October. Eight months before that, in February of last year, the mayor refused interview requests about the city’s infrastructure.

By ducking questions, Mr. Gainey is avoiding any accountability for his city’s deteriorating bridges and other public assets that endanger public safety.

Advertise with us

On March 8 of last year, in a public appeal to the state House Democratic Policy Committee for more infrastructure resources, Mr. Gainey called it his top priority. “If we’re not responding to this, this is not an office we should be in,” he said. We agree.

The mayor should remember his words from last spring, before his own administration crumbles and collapses.