Pennsylvania school districts routinely obscure the amount of their cash reserves, allowing them to raise taxes without referendums, a report from auditor general Timothy DeFoor has found. This gaping loophole makes a mockery of Act 1 of 2006, which purports to protect taxpayers from needless or nonessential property tax increases.

State legislators should close this loophole by making sure school districts account for all of their reserve funds, not just those tucked away in the general fund. Now, districts, including North Allegheny, conceal reserve cash by shifting it from the general fund to other accounts.

Act 1 prohibits school districts from unilaterally raising taxes without a voter-approved referendum — if their “unreserved, undesignated” fund balances, which are generally reserved for the general fund, exceed 8% of their total budgets.

Aside from the general fund, however, districts maintain several other unrestricted accounts that are designated for specific uses, such as capital improvements or pension fund contributions. These “designated” funds currently do not count toward the 8% cap on reserves.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeFoor and his team reviewed the books of 12 Pennsylvania school districts, including North Allegheny, Canon-McMillan and Hempfield Area, that kept unusually high cash reserves, and found they kept their “undesignated, unreserved” balances below the 8% threshold by moving money out of the general fund to other accounts. In fact, 8 of the 12 districts had official, written policies to ensure their general funds were below the referendum-triggering figure.

Those nontransparent practices allowed the 12 districts to raise taxes 37 times, out of a possible 48, between fiscal years 2018 and 2021, while avoiding politically dicey referendums.

Even more troubling, districts would routinely fail to use the money set aside in reserved accounts for their stated purpose. The were “reserved” in name only, allowing districts to keep high balances while raising taxes without asking the voters — precisely the practice Act 1 sought to eliminate.

Mr. DeFoor’s audit recommends that the legislature tweak the language of the taxpayer protection provision by changing “undesignated, unreserved” to “unrestricted.” That would ensure districts can’t simply declare some funds “reserved” to skirt referendums. The report states that if the 8% threshold included all “unrestricted” funds, the 12 audited districts would, together, have been able to raise taxes only 11 times over four years.

Oversight of school finances is essential. School districts have gotten away with deceptive practices partly because of the complexities of their accounting and finances, which include, among other things, uncertain and inconsistent property tax revenues, state funding and bond and investment market earnings.

School districts, of course, want the flexibility to keep deep reserves and also raise taxes without the political risks of a referendum. It’s a good deal for them, but a bad deal for the taxpayers that pay for school districts. The legislature must close this loophole to make the taxpayer protection law worthy of its name.