Racial insensitivity and racism surrounding a state championship football game between a mostly white and mostly Black high school underscores the need for stricter guidelines on racial bias. The Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association (PIAA), whose bylaws govern high school sports statewide, should craft rules before the next high school football season that make schools accountable for acts of racism, even if unintended.

On Friday, mostly Black Westinghouse High School and mostly white Southern Columbia battled for a state championship. Southern Columbia won the game, 37-22, in a hard-fought battle that was much closer than the score suggests. It ended a dream season for the Westinghouse football team and their revered coach, Donta Green. The team’s 14-game win streak had fueled media coverage across the state.

But media coverage of the championship game quickly shifted, due to signs made by cheerleaders and hung at an off-site pep rally, and a post-game TikTok video that included two white Southern Columbia players using a snippet of rap music that includes a racial slur.

There may be contexts in which the phrases “Whip Westinghouse” and “Southern State of Mind” have no racial overtones. Likewise, the context of a Black artist on a rap song is different from a bus load of white football players celebrating a victory over a mostly Black high school. The racial overtones, even if not intended, are insidious.

Advertise with us

It is unfair to the young men of Westinghouse that racial insensitivity or racism has eclipsed a storied run to the state championship game. This incident is a reminder of the ubiquity of racism and a clarion call for change.

As it stands, the only mention of race in the PIAA bylaws is in its sportsmanship policy, which prohibits student athletes from using race “to bait, intimidate, or denigrate an opponent.” On-field taunts based on racial prejudice can result in penalties against the offending team.

With respect to fans and schools, the athletic association practically punts. It says only that unsportsmanlike conduct, or condoning or supporting it, violates the code and can trigger “any and all remedial measures available to PIAA.” This is much too vague, and leaves athletes from marginalized communities vulnerable to abuse that is dismissed as spontaneous or ambiguous.

The PIAA needs to make it clear that if a school is not vigilant about racial bias — even indirect or ambiguous words or actions — its programs can be sanctioned. Acts of racial bias among a school’s supporters are indicative of broader cultural and institutional problems. It is perfectly reasonable for the PIAA to insist that schools proactively communicate with and educate their students and supporters about what will not be tolerated, and to codify a specific punishment, such as exclusion from championship contests, for racist behavior.

Coach Donta Green at  Westinghouse has worked tirelessly to build not only a great football team, but also the character of his players. In a conversation earlier this year with the Post-Gazette’s Mike White, senior quarterback Keyshawn Morsillo said, “He’s changed us. Everyone on the football team used to have, you know, that ‘hood’ culture. But he has showed us the right way to be a successful Black man. We look up to him, follow his footsteps. Really, he’s helping turn us from boys to men.”

Advertise with us

Actions that further stigmatize, even if only implicitly, the Westinghouse boys on the basis of race undermine the progress Mr. Green has made. They tell his players that no matter how “successful” they become, no matter how much they do things the “right way,” they are still seen first and foremost as Black kids — that is, as members of a racial underclass. When Black excellence is met with and overshadowed by racism, it can make kids trying to do their best wonder: “Why bother?”

It’s a core tenet of the PIAA to protect student athletes. The Westinghouse/Southern Columbia incident is an opportunity for the PIAA to strengthen its commitment to protecting its athletes by drafting stronger and more specific rules and punishments for racially harmful actions — whether from players, coaches or supporters.